So we beat on, boats against the current, borne back ceaselessly into the past. Brexit is the wound that will never heal, despite the ministrations of countless Grail knights. More than 10 years have passed and still our politics is defined by the sliding doors moment of the EU referendum. Everything dragging us back to that June day in 2016. The further we get from it, the closer it becomes. Something only Stephen Hawking could have explained. And then, only to himself. The rest of us would have been none the wiser.
For the most part, we’ve tried to avoid talking about the subject. At least in public. It’s considered impolite, an intrusion into a national grief. In private, most people now admit the country is worse off than we were before we left the EU. But it is a pain and misfortune that must be borne stoically. The people had spoken. And the people can never be wrong. Except when they are.
Even the loudest cheerleaders for Brexit find themselves mumbling that it hasn’t gone as they had planned. Not that they had planned anything. Which was half the problem. The whole deal with Brexit before the referendum was that it could mean whatever you wanted it to mean. Sovereignty. Not sovereignty. Leaving the single market. Staying in the single market. Leaving the customs union. Not leaving the customs union. Everyone could have a Brexit in which they could believe.
It was only after the referendum that things began to fall apart as the Brexiters tried to pin down what leaving the EU meant. Only the UK could have chosen a prime minister as hopeless as Theresa May, whose main contribution was to say “Brexit means Brexit”. She was sacrificed on the altar of her own futility, to be replaced by Boris Johnson. Perhaps it was always going to take a liar and a chancer to get some kind of Brexit deal through parliament. It was only later that the Brexiters came to understand that lowering immigration actually meant increasing it exponentially.
But now we have a prime minister who is prepared to say the previously unsayable. In his Mansion House speech on Monday evening, Andy Burnham is expected to reveal that the emperor has no clothes. Whichever way you cut it, Brexit has been a failure. The UK is worse off now than it was before the referendum. Now is the time to abandon our traditional British reserve.
There would be no truth and reconciliation committee. Just a clean slate. Tabula rasa. No one will be judging anyone. Much. Simply take the plunge and try to find a way to reset the UK’s relationship with Europe. It can be whatever the people want. Rejoining the EU. Single market and customs union. Or just kisses and cuddles. The people would decide. Given that the people had got it so spectacularly wrong last time, this wasn’t a huge comfort. But needs must. You have to start from somewhere.
Mind you, not everyone was willing to put all their reservations to one side. In the 8.10am interview slot on BBC Radio 4’s Today programme, the presenter Nick Robinson was determined to give Ed Miliband, the foreign secretary, as hard a time as possible. “You seem to think that any fool can see it’s a good idea to get closer to Europe,” he said. It was like entering a time machine again. Conjuring nightmares of David Cameron and Boris. Both of whom have declared that we should stay as distant from the EU as humanly possible. Which rather suggests Burnham is right. Lord Big Dave and Boris have rather been proved wrong on almost everything so far.
Miliband is too long in the tooth to be caught out like that. You could sense he was dying to say: “Of course any fool can see it’s a good idea to get closer to the EU,” because that’s what almost every listener was thinking. Instead, he said: “The prime minister was more nuanced than that….” Before going on to as good as say you’d need to be a complete halfwit to imagine we are better off now than we were before Brexit. Because what else was there to add. You can’t find a thinktank anywhere that believes Brexit has benefited the economy, immigration and national security.
It was now becoming obvious that Robbo’s heart wasn’t really in the interview. He’s the one who likes to have politicians on the ropes, not the other way round. And now he was left to play devil’s advocate by mentioning the five carrot growers in the UK who might be worse off if we did reset food regulations with the EU. But Ed was nothing if not generous. Plus, he might be needing a favour from Nick some time in the future. So rather than laugh, he nodded earnestly. He was very conscious that the five carrot growers might find life tougher, but maybe we should be thinking of the many thousands of food producers whose business would be markedly improved. Call it honours even.