Closing summary
That’s all from me, Tom Ambrose, and the UK live politics blog on the day that Zack Polanski’s Green party was left reeling from last night’s byelection result.
Here is a round-up of the day’s stories:
-
Labour has seen off the Greens to win the Holborn and St Pancras byelection in a result that will reassure Andy Burnham and dent Zack Polanski’s position as a decisive power player on the left of British politics. The byelection, called after the former prime minister Keir Starmer resigned from the seat in September, was considered a two-horse race between the Labour candidate, Sagal Abdi-Wali, and the Green party leader, Polanski.
-
Abdi-Wali received 12,292 votes, 45% of the vote, to Polanski’s 8,928, 33% of the vote. Turnout was 38.7%, the lowest for any byelection held in England during this parliament and 15.4 percentage points down from the 2024 general election.
-
Speaking to the BBC after the result, Polanski insisted he would remain in his post. “Of course I can carry on as leader of the Green party,” he said. “We’re a party of 220,000 members. I’ve taken a loss tonight but our movement is so much bigger than one election or one motion and we’re going to grow.”
-
The Green MP Siân Berry has said that many members who, like her, were opposed to the “Zionism is racism” motion at conference were “persuaded” not to publicly campaign against it because of the byelection happening at the same time. In a statement today, she says she accepts that passing the motion has done “genuine damage” to the party’s reputation. Berry argued and voted against it, but she says she should have done more to kill it off and she apologises.
-
Caroline Lucas, the former Green leader, has said that Sunday’s vote for the “Zionism is racism” motion has shown how the party is “woefully exposed” to entryism. In an article for the New Statesman, she said passing the motion crossed “a very significant red line” and she said the party urgently needed to reform its internal procedures to stop this happening again.
-
The leader of the Jewish Greens has called for Zack Polanski to step down as pressure increases on the Green leader to acknowledge anger within the party over a new policy that equates Zionism with racism and calls for the state of Israel to be abolished. The comments by Vivien Lichtenstein come after Caroline Lucas, the Greens’ former leader and first MP, criticised Polanski for a lack of leadership in missing the debate and vote at the weekend that resulted in the policy being passed.
-
Polanski was asked about reports that Lubna Speitan, one of the Green party members proposing the “Zionism is racism” motion, was listed in court documents as a “close friend” of a man later jailed for supporting al-Qaeda. Polanski said that he was not aware of this at the time of the debate. But he said this was now being investigated by the party.
-
A senior Liberal Democrat MP has quit the party’s front bench in what is reported to be an effort to topple leader Ed Davey. The party confirmed that Charlie Maynard, the MP for Witney, had quit as a Treasury spokesman on Friday. The Financial Times reported that the resignation is intended to trigger Davey’s removal.
-
Robert Jenrick has launched an extended attack on Kemi Badenoch, calling her part of a metropolitan elite and saying a coalition deal with the Tories would be like being “handcuffed to a zombie”. Reform UK’s economics spokesperson repeatedly called the Tory leader “Kensington Kemi” and claimed her party was for people who moaned about the decline of Mayfair clubs and complained that they could not find Ottolenghi recipe ingredients in the shops.
-
Andy Burnham has pledged to make dementia research a national priority as he announced a £48m industry partnership to accelerate the search for a cure, the Press Association reports. The prime minister, whose father Roy died last month after suffering from Alzheimer’s, told the Innovation Nation Summit in Manchester much had been done to battle cancers but not enough on dementia.
-
The Labour chair of the Commons housing committee is urging John Healey to bring forward billions of pounds of planned spending on social and affordable homes in England, after housing associations said they were ready to build tens of thousands more. Abena Oppong-Asare called for the chancellor to allocate money from the £39bn Social and Affordable Homes Programme (SAHP) as soon as possible, rather than after the election as planned.
-
Tax cuts for big banks have deprived the UK government of £6bn in revenues, according to campaigners, who are calling on the chancellor, John Healey, to increase taxes and force lenders to pay their “fair share” in the budget. Calculations by the Trades Union Congress (TUC), which represents unions with more than 5.3 million members across England and Wales, shows that the public purse is billions of pounds worse off as a result of tax cuts introduced under the Tory chancellor Rishi Sunak in 2023.
-
Kemi Badenoch’s flagship party conference policy document overestimated the cost of net zero by nearly £500bn, seemingly after someone accidentally double-counted figures on a spreadsheet. The apparent error appears in a chapter on net zero in The Right Way, a 100-page policy document produced for the Conservative conference in Birmingham. Badenoch repeatedly used the phrase in her main speech.
Lib Dem MP quits front bench 'in bid to topple Ed Davey'
A senior Liberal Democrat MP has quit the party’s front bench in what is reported to be an effort to topple leader Ed Davey.
The party confirmed that Charlie Maynard, the MP for Witney, had quit as a Treasury spokesman on Friday. The Financial Times reported that the resignation is intended to trigger Davey’s removal.
Maynard is reported to have asked parliamentary colleagues to back a vote of no confidence in the leader.
Lib Dem deputy leader Daisy Cooper backed Davey, saying the “vast majority” of the party’s MPs wanted him to remain as leader and were “furious at this distraction”.
She said:
We Liberal Democrats are the last line of defence against a Reform UK government, and Ed is determined to lead a strong and united party into the next general election whenever it comes.
As Ed said at conference we are in the fight of our lives against the right who want to turn our country into their version of Trump’s America.
Tax cuts for big banks have deprived the UK government of £6bn in revenues, according to campaigners, who are calling on the chancellor, John Healey, to increase taxes and force lenders to pay their “fair share” in the budget.
Calculations by the Trades Union Congress (TUC), which represents unions with more than 5.3 million members across England and Wales, shows that the public purse is billions of pounds worse off as a result of tax cuts introduced under the Tory chancellor Rishi Sunak in 2023.
The then government agreed to slash the bank surcharge – an additional levy on lenders’ profits – from 8% to 3% that year. The move was meant to offset a rise in corporation tax from 19% to 25%, after the industry argued higher taxes would put them at a competitive disadvantage compared with other big financial centres such as New York.
However, the cuts came just as lenders started reaping handsome earnings, thanks to rising interest rates. The UK’s four largest lenders – HSBC, NatWest, Barclays, Lloyds Banking Group – have now generated £200bn in pre-tax profits over the past five years.
The TUC says the 2023 cuts ultimately robbed the UK purse of tax revenues. Its analysis of HMRC corporate tax receipts shows the UK public lost out £2.3bn in 2023-24, a further £1.7bn in 2024-25, and £2bn in 2025-26 – totalling £6bn over three years.
Reform UK’s Robert Jenrick has said a pact with the Conservatives would be like “being handcuffed to a zombie”.
The party’s Treasury spokesman insisted Reform is not interested in such an agreement, just a day after its leader Nigel Farage refused to rule it out.
Farage told the Press Association on Thursday a pact before the next election is “extremely unlikely”, but added:
After an election, who’s to say?
It came after Kemi Badenoch used her Conservative party conference speech on Wednesday to reject the idea of a deal, saying: “To those who say ‘unite the right’, we are not uniting with that.”
Speaking to reporters on Friday, Jenrick said:
The Tories ruling out a deal with Reform is like me saying to Thomas Tuchel that I’m ruling out being selected for the England squad versus Croatia.
I mean, doing a deal with the Tory party is like being handcuffed to a zombie. It’s not something we’re interested in, trust me.
Former Green co-leader Jonathan Bartley says party has acquired 'a certain toxicity' under Polanski's leadership
Many of the most senior figures in the Green party – its MPs, former leaders and peers – have expressed concerns about the party allowing the “Zionism is racism” motion to pass, and Zack Polanski’s role in what happened.
In an interview on the World at One, Jonathan Bartley, a former co-leader, joined this chorus. He said that allegations of antisemitism meant there was now “a certain toxicity” around the party, and he accused Polanski of a failure of leadership.
Bartley said that in some respects Polanski had done a “really good job” as leader. But the Zionism motion was not handled well, he said. He went on:
As Caroline Lucas said on Newsnight last night, it was a failure of leadership from Zack. [See 2.55am.]
And there is a certain toxicity now around the Green party which clearly is gaining some traction.
We’re losing a lot of older voters. The demographic has become younger and younger. I think we’re polling now at levels we were at when I stepped down as leader in 2021, around 9%.
Bartley said Polanski was not to blame for this toxicity problem, which he said was caused by the huge influx of new members to the Greens. But he said that Polanski had not handled the conference debate well, and that he now needed to repair the damage.
I think he needs to put his hands up where he’s made a mistake. I think he needs to say I’m sorry. I think the membership will be forgiving. I think, actually, the electorate will be forgiving. But the Green party brand – I don’t like that word very much – needs to be detoxified …
What’s Zack’s job now? Zack’s job is to lead us out of that. Zack’s job is to say we don’t do purity tests, we have a different culture, we are about peacemaking and dealing with conflict well.
Bartley described Polanski as “very gifted in some respects, and less so in others”.
He said he expected Polanski to face a leadership challenge next year – but that he was likely to win because of his popularity with members.
That is all from me for today. Tom Ambrose is taking over.
Green MP Siân Berry says opponents of Zionism motion were 'persuaded' not to fight it publicly because of byelection
The Green MP Siân Berry has said that many members who, like her, were opposed to the “Zionism is racism” motion at conference were “persuaded” not to publicly campaign against it because of the byelection happening at the same time. In a statement today, she says she accepts that passing the motion has done “genuine damage” to the party’s reputation. Berry argued and voted against it, but she says she should have done more to kill it off and she apologises.
She also says that she is glad Zack Polanski has now said he would have voted against the motion that was passed had he been there, and she urges the party to fix the flaws in it.
Berry does not say whether any particular individuals persuaded her not to campaign against the motion in public, or whether she is just referring to a general climate of opinion in the party.
As Megan Kenyon from the New Statesman reports, Greens Organise, a Green party group that campaigned for Zack Polanski to become leader, has issued a statement saying he deserves to stay on as leader.
Here is an extract.
A year ago, Zack started us on this journey - we surged to over 220,000 members, won control of multiple Councils and beat Reform in Gorton & Denton. We shook Labour to its core and forced a Prime Minister to resign.
But not all growth and success is linear, there will be ups and downs; the real test for a political organisation is how we deal with failure.
We have re-shaped the British political landscape. The Green Party can still become the ecosocialist party we need. Zack is still the leader who can get us there.
Peter Walker and Alexandra Topping are talking about the Holborn and St Pancras byelection in the latest edition of our Politics Weekly UK podcast.
Compass, the leftwing group campaigning for more pluralism in progressive politics, has issued a long statement saying the Holborn and St Pancras byelection shows why Labour and the Green party should work together.
Here is an extract.
Last night was both triumph and tragedy for the Green Party. A tragedy because they failed to win a seat that only six months ago they probably would have secured. But weirdly, unexpectedly and unintendedly it is also a triumph. For it is undoubtedly the Greens who have done as much as anyone to rid the country of Starmerism. By mounting a credible political and electoral threat to Labour’s left, realised most spectacularly in the Gorton and Denton by-election and then in May’s local elections, the Greens showed that progressives did have somewhere else to go. And that changed everything. Much to the displeasure of Labour’s right, the party were forced to crown, without a contest, the only politician in the country who has a chance to meet both the twin threats of Reform and the Greens – Andy Burnham …
If we are to rewire the state, bring in proportional representation, tackle the cost of living crisis and even begin to reverse 40 years of neoliberalism, we cannot afford to work against one another.
The Greens are unlikely to replace Labour. But Labour, short on money, short of a mandate and absent of pressure from the Greens, are unlikely to be as radical as the moment demands. We are in this together.
Jenrick claims Badenoch has turned Tories into party just for rich, with her 'Belgravia bung' costing average worker £265
At the Conservative party conference this week, Robert Jenrick, the party’s former justice spokesperson and Kemi Badenoch’s main rival in the leadership contest, was elevated to the status of the party’s chief villain. That’s because of his defection to Reform UK, or his role as a “turncoat” as it was put in the party’s spoof Bayeaux Tapestry.
This morning “the turncoat”, who is now Reform UK’s Treasury spokesperson, gave a speech. It was about the economic choices facing the country, and included criticism of Labour, but Jenrick sounded at his most passionate when he was laying into former colleagues.
Jenrick pointed out that the main policy announcements at the Tory conference favoured the very rich. He explained:
People earning a hundred and fifty grand a year will get free childcare.
People in £2m houses will get a council tax cut.
And if the people who pass away in that mansion have £1m more in the bank, they’ll pay nothing whatsoever.
Kensington Kemi knows who her people are.
Millionaires, not Mansfield.
Jenrick said the main Tory announcement, exempting homes from inheritance tax, would “only benefit one person in 245 in the east Midlands, one in 472 in the north-east [and] almost nobody outside of London and the south-east”.
He went on:
I’ll just come out and say it.
The party of Disraeli is dead.
He said “The Tory party, unless it is a national party, is nothing.”
Well they’re not even pretending to be a national party now.
What’s left is nothing more than a metropolitan pressure group for the wealthiest.
They have simply given up on the millions of people that have the misfortune of having to work for a living ….
And, who is paying for Badenoch’s bung to Belgravia? Working families.
The Tories decided not to cut the jobs tax [Labour’s rise in employer national insurance], crippling businesses and costing jobs.
She decided not to unfreeze the income tax threshold, which is punishing more and more working people.
She won’t cut taxes on the self-employed. Or make life easier for tradesmen.
In real terms, under her plan, the average worker would pay £265 more than they did under Rachel Reeves.
And she’s taking that 265 quid and giving it to her mates in their central London mansions.
Jenrick went on:
I’ve got to level with you. I have never been happier to be shot of that dying cult.
Because the Tory party has turned its back on everybody I am in politics for.
This wasn’t just a surrender of the red wall. It was the Tories saying to everyone who has to work to get on in life: get stuffed.
Gone are Essex or Workington Man. Gone is Worcester Woman.
In their place, nepo-babies and a new plan to go after Lib Dem voters. Well, fine.
Leader of Jewish Greens says Polanski should resign
Vivien Lichtenstein, the leader of the Jewish Greens, has called for Zack Polanski to step down as pressure increases on the Green leader to acknowledge anger within the party over a new policy which equates Zionism with racism and calls for the state of Israel to be abolished. Peter Walker has the story.
Here are some more responses to the Holborn and St Pancras byelection result from journalists and commentators.
From Patrick English from YouGov
Just to temper the chat a little bit around what will yes definitely be a morning of disappointment for the Greens... This was not a seat we would *expect* them to win. It is not like other areas in London where they did so well in May (Hackey, Lewisham, Waltham Forest).
From the politics professor Steven Fielding
For any governing party in modern times defending a seat midterm, this is a very good result. But it’s not so good Burnham should even think about holding an early general election.
From the New Statesman’s Ben Walker
Grns performed as Britain Predicts expects. But Lab outperform.
To what extent that is...
A greater willingness to tactically vote Lab to beat the Grns
And/or
A reflection of the Labour bounce in London ...
needs some research. Will change a few dynamics either way.
From Adam Ramsay, a journalist and Green party member
I remember, not so long ago, Greens got c. 4% in a by-election, and my reaction was “well, at least it wasn’t totally humiliating”. The fact that some people think 33% in a longstanding Labour seat in the middle of the Burnham bounce is bad shows how far the party has come.
From the Economist’s Owen Winter
There’s a fine line between righteous anger over the war in Gaza and seeming obsessive/extreme. Big difference speaking to voters in Holborn and St Pancras compared with Gorton and Denton was how many felt the Greens had moved into the second category
From George Eaton from the Arguably Substack
Zack Polanski repeatedly declared that the Greens were “replacing” Labour and said he was “incredibly confident” of winning Holborn & St Pancras. Finishing 12.8 points behind cannot be spun as a “good” result.
Back to the byelection, and the politics professor Rob Ford has written an analysis of the results for Sky News. Here is an excerpt.
This was a strong performance for Labour on several metrics. The decline in Labour’s vote share, at just 3.7 points, was well below the average drop of 19.3 points across the four by-elections during Starmer’s premiership, where Burnham was not on the ballot.
The drop here was indeed smaller than the average drop in Labour support found during Tony Blair’s first term (11.1%).
The Labour to Green swing, at 13.1 points, was well below many of the swings the Greens achieved in the 2024 general election and this May’s local elections, and a pale shadow of the 26.5-point swing the party achieved in Gorton and Denton in February.
Burnham unveils £48m partnership in bid to 'defeat' dementia
Andy Burnham has pledged to make dementia research a national priority as he announced a £48m industry partnership to accelerate the search for a cure, the Press Association reports. PA says:
The prime minister, whose father Roy died last month after suffering from Alzheimer’s, said he wanted Britain “to be the country that makes the breakthrough”.
The government will invest £33m, and there is also funding from Bristol Myers Squibb, GSK and Gates Ventures to help recruit more people for clinical studies.
The investment will support The Barbara Alliance, which was launched in memory of the late EastEnders actress Dame Barbara Windsor to speed up the development of dementia treatments.
It will establish a platform connecting health data, research and clinical trial capabilities to make it easier to find participants for trials.
Burnham said:
Dementia is a devastatingly cruel disease, not only for those who live with it, but for the families who care for them.
For too long, we have accepted dementia as something to be managed later in life, rather than a disease we can defeat.
I don’t accept that.
In fact, I have real hope that we can come together and do exactly that.
Downing Street has published further details here.
Caroline Lucas says Green party urgently needs to revise its policy-making rules because it's 'woefully exposed' to entryism
Caroline Lucas, the former Green leader, has said that Sunday’s vote for the “Zionism is racism” motion has shown how the party is “woefully exposed” to entryism.
In an article for the New Statesman, she said passing the motion crossed “a very significant red line” and she said the party urgently needed to reform its internal procedures to stop this happening again.
She explained:
It’s worth recalling that this motion was supported by 1,022 self-selected members – just 0.5% of the party’s total membership – an unknown number of whom were actively encouraged to join the Green party simply to vote to push the motion through. This speaks volumes about the vulnerability of our internal structures. Entryism has been a problem for many parties, but with our commitment to direct democracy and our cumbersome internal accountability mechanisms, the Greens are woefully exposed.
In the weeks and months to come, we Greens have urgent work to do: taking action to show everyone in our communities, especially Jewish people, that our party is safe for them; finding ways of making our party’s policy making processes more inclusive and effective, our internal structures more accountable and resilient, and our understanding of both antisemitism and Zionism more informed.
Setting out what she saw as the flaw in the motion, Lucas said:
One of the most dangerous outcomes of rising populism and polarisation is a refusal to accept complexities, to deal only in zero-sum binaries. And so the radical over-simplification at the heart of the “Zionism is racism” motion has led to many Jewish people, both inside and outside the party, feeling scared and unwelcome. For many of them, the knowledge about why their ancestors or families fled Europe and sought sanctuary in Palestine can, and often does, simultaneously sit alongside their utter abhorrence at the actions and ideology of the state of Israel now. But asking all Jewish people to deny the historical realities that might explain their own families’ attachment to Israel as a sanctuary is not an ask our movement should or needs to make.
In his speech in Manchester, Andy Burnham congratulated Sagal Abdi-Wali on her victory in the byelection.
He said:
We’re here in Manchester. But actually, it’s good news from London that it’s lifting us. And I just wanted to say congratulations to Sagal Abdi-Wali, the new member of parliament for Holborn and St Pancras – and, relevant to this morning, the constituency that is the capital of innovation in the UK, home to the Crick Institute, the Alan Turing Institute and so much more.
These are from the More in Common pollster Luke Tryl on the Holborn and St Pancras byelection result.
3000+ majority for Labour, comfortable and a sign of Burnham’s gains on the left. Labour vote barely drops. Green vote significantly up from 2024, but less impressive if you assume lots of Feinstein 2024 voters went to the Greens. Bad result for the Greens but not at worst end
Wider context to the Holborn result: this chart shows the proportion of Labour’s 2024 vote going to different parties. Post Gorton over 1 in 10 Labour 24 voters were going to the Greens - that number has more than halved as Labour’s retention improved, particularly on the left.
Tryl also points out that it was a record bad result for George Galloway, who in the past has pulled off two remarkable byelection victories.
Obviously not helped by the fact he is in self imposed exile. But Holborn was George Galloway’s worst ever result in a Westminster election.
Here is Guardian video of Zack Polanski responding to the byelection result.
Party leaders sometimes visit the constituency after a byelection win. Andy Burnham is giving a speech this morning – but not in Holborn and St Pancras. He is in Manchester, where he is giving a speech at the Innovation Nation summit.
Burnham is speaking now, and he is following the former PM Gordon Brown. Brown said the UK could be a leading innovation nation, and Burnham started his speech with what he said were words that he used every week when he was a cabinet minister almost 20 years ago. “Gordon is right,” he said.
Polanski says he wants Green party to revise its Zionism motion 'at earliest opportunity'
Jenny Jones, the Green party peer, said that the Greens should clarify what they meant by the “Zionism is racism” motion passed at their conference.
Describing the vote “a rather big blip” for the party in an interview on Times Radio, she said:
I actually chaired the session and I was astonished. It was very emotional, but it was also relatively polite, which was surprising.
And I would like to see it reorganised. It is not clear exactly what we mean.
Zack has been working with Jewish members of the party and with Jewish organisations to make it clear that we are not antisemitic.
And nobody in the party will be disciplined for going to the synagogue or any sort of community centre.
We have to work through it and we’ve got to make it clear exactly what that motion means.
In his Today interview, Polanski also said that he would like the party to revise the motion. He said:
At the earliest possible opportunity, I do want, at a conference motion, to see us go back to a process where Israelis and Palestinians decide the future of their region.
Now, that’s up to members because we’re a grassroots party.
Polanski declines to say Israel has right to exist, but insists he does not back replacing it with single Palestinian state
On the Today programme (see 9.12am) Zack Polanski was being interviewed by Nick Robinson. At times, it got rather tetchy.
When Robinson asked about Caroline Lucas saying that Polanski should have voted in the debate on the “Zionism is racism” motion (see 2.55am), Polanski said he was fighting a byelection. Robinson then told him not to “insult the intelligence of people listening” and said that of course he could have been at the debate. Polanski said he had in fact pushed to get the conference postponed.
Asked how he would have voted if he had been there, Polanski said he wanted to amend the motion on two grounds. But those amendments fell. “And so I would have voted against the motion,” he said.
Polanski backed taking out the reference in the motion saying there should be a one-state solution, and another amendment that would have ensured Jewish Green members were not penalised for belonging to synagogues that identify as Zionist.
Asked if he believed there should be “a safe home for Jews in a state called Israel”, Polanski replied:
I believe everyone deserves a safe home, and I’ve not dodged the question.
When Robinson asked again if Israel had a right to exist, Polanski said:
I believe Israelis and Palestinians should have equal rights in a democracy …
Right now, Israel is a one-state, apartheid state. Palestinians don’t have democracy and they don’t have the right to vote for their government.
Robinson asked why Polanski was not able to say he believed in Israel as a safe home for Jewish people, even if he loathed what its government was doing. Polanski replied:
I don’t believe that any state has a right to oppress or to commit apartheid, and certainly not genocide, on another people.
Now, it may be that in the future that there is a solution in which case Israelis and Palestinians can have equal rights.
I believe my role as leader of the Green party, and more importantly the British government, is to uphold international law.
But this is a context where we’ve seen 75,000 Palestinians murdered in the last few years, 1,500 murdered since the so-called ceasefire, and there are more child amputees than in modern history.
I don’t believe that’s a state that anyone should be supporting.
Robinson asked about the distinction between the Israeli government and the Israeli state. Was Polanski saying things were so terrible the state of Israel should no longer exist? Robinson said the motion passed at the Green conference implied this because it proposed a single Palestinian state. Did Polanski want to scrap the state of Israel?
Polanski replied:
No. What I want is to see a safe space for Israelis and Palestinians. And by the way, this isn’t a new position. We could go back to Edward Montagu, a Jewish man who was in the cabinet, who said at the time that he felt Zionism was a racist endeavour against Jewish people …
Jewish people have always had different opinions about the state of Israel.
Robinson intervened:
I still don’t know what your position is, whether it has a right to exist or not. You could just give me a yes/no and we could move on.
Polanski said he wanted to equal rights for Israeli and Palestinians. Robinson said that was not an answer to the question. Polanski replied: “At the moment Palestinians don’t have equal rights, so I think I’m answering your question really clearly.”
And Andy Burnham has posted this message on the result.
Yesterday, Holborn and St Pancras voted for hope.
Congratulations @Sagal_AW and the whole team on a fantastic campaign. Looking forward to working together!
Keir Starmer, the former PM, has posted this on social media about Sagal Abdi-Wali winning the byelection created by his resignation as MP for Holborn and St Pancras.
Brilliant result. Congratulations to my friend @Sagal_AW, I know you are a brilliant champion for our communities and will be a fantastic MP.
Polanski says Green party investigating member proposing Zionism motion over friendship with convicted terrorist
In an interview on the Today programme, Zack Polanski was asked about reports that Lubna Speitan, one of the Green party members proposing the “Zionism is racism” motion, was listed in court documents as a “close friend” of a man later jailed for supporting al-Qaeda.
Polanski said that he was not aware of this at the time of the debate. But he said this was now being investigated by the party.
When it was put to him that, given the importance of this motion, he should have looked who was proposing it more carefully, Polanski said there were 121 motions proposed at the conference.
Asked about her friendship with Minh Quang Pham, who denied planning a suicide attack, Speitan told the Telegraph: “People are demonised for all sorts of things and wrongfully accused of all sorts of things.” She also claimed she was the victim of a “character assassination”.
Here is an extract from Prof Sir John Curtice’s assessment of the Holborn and St Pancras byelection in an article for the Times.
With 45 per cent of the vote, Labour was much further ahead of the Greens, on 33 per cent, than they had been in May. Yet, Labour’s tally was still four points down on the 49 per cent Sir Keir won in 2024 — a figure that, as in many constituencies with a substantial Muslim population, was well down on the 66 per cent the party won locally in 2019.
In short, the result confirmed that, while it is enjoying a substantial recovery from the nadir to which the party fell in the final months of Sir Keir’s tenure, Labour still has significant ground left to recover before it is in a position where it might win another Commons majority.
Curtice also points out that the results confirm that Restore Britain is a problem for Reform UK. (See 6.15am.) The Conservative party came third, but Reform UK would beaten the Tories if its candidate had also had just half the votes that went to Restore.
Updated
Here is a Guardian graphic showing how the share of the vote changed in the Holborn and St Pancras byelection since the 2024 election.
And this is what Bridget Phillipson, the Labour party chair, told Times Radio about the byelection result.
I think it demonstrates that Labour’s message of hope is really cutting through, that people don’t just want parties like Labour to talk about the progressive change this country needs but they want to see it delivered in action, and that’s what we’re focused on every day as a Labour government.
The things that really matter to people about the cost of living, about issues around homelessness as Sagal [Abdi-Wali] was talking about.
In Sagal we had a fantastic candidate who really resonated with the public, backed up by Labour’s clear message of hope and I couldn’t be more pleased.
Bridget Phillipson, the Labour party chair, told Sky News that the Holborn and St Pancras byelection result showed that Andy Burnham had “got off to an incredibly strong start” as PM.
Holborn and St Pancras byelection loss will disappoint Greens, but there may also be relief - Peter Walker's analysis
Here is Peter Walker’s assessment of the Holborn and St Pancras byelection result. He says Zack Polanski should be relieved his result wasn’t any worse.
Here is an extract.
Polanski got just under 33% of the vote, well above anyone else apart from Abdi-Wali, a proportion which shows that in an another election, and up against a Labour party not enjoying a Burnham bounce, the Greens could still be highly competitive in seats like these …
It was notable that after the result, Polanski had to insist that he intended to stay as Green leader. “Yes absolutely, that’s what leaders do,” he replied.
While some in the Greens had questioned Polanski’s decision to contest a seat in north London, rather than east London, where he lives, his allies make the point that Nigel Farage took eight tries to become an MP.
Either way, the result has not made Polanski’s position any worse. Had the Green vote collapsed he would have been under very intense pressure. As it stands, he must try to reassure sceptics in the party before seeking re-election in a year from now, under the party’s policy of two-year terms for leaders.
And here is the full article.
Polanski plays down claims his leadership under threat, and says he will stand again for parliament
Under Green party rules, leaders have to get re-elected every two years, which means there will be a contest next summer. Asked how confident he was of being able to win again, Polanski told Sky News:
What I’m experiencing is the immense amount of people who are saying they’ve never been prouder to be a Green party member.
It is being difficult being leader of any party, particularly the Green party or a decentralised party.
Very often the media – and I think this is fine that they do that - talk about the Green -arty as if we’re like the other parties. But that is a different kind of party. We’re led by the grassroots and ultimately the leader is partly a primary spokesperson for the party. That is difficult. But I signed up for that difficult job, and I’m more than ready to continue.
Asked if he would stand again to be an MP, he replied:
I want to be an MP. I don’t think it’s the be all and end all. I think I’ve demonstrated over the last year that you can create change from outside of parliament.
But, if another seat came up in London where he had a connection, he would stand again, he said.
Polanski rejects claim by Caroline Lucas that he failed to show leadership as Greens debating Zionism motion
Asked about Caroline Lucas, the former Green party leader, saying that he failed to show leadership during the Zionism debate and that he should have voted (see 2.55am), Polanski replied:
There was a national byelection going on, one of the most important elections in our recent history. And people in that election said they wanted to see me on the ground. They wanted to see me dealing with local issues. So I did exactly that. I went on the ground and dealt with local issues.
In terms of me and Caroline, I think we’re actually united in making sure that we want to push this government for a two-way arms embargo to stop selling arms licenses and F-35 components to fighter jets, to make sure that we’ve got boycott, divestment and sanctions, and to push Andy Burnham.
Ed Miliband, the foreign secretary, has said many people were right about Gaza, but they’re still arresting pensioners for holding up cardboard signs saying I support Palestine Action.
Polanski accepted that Lucas was still a “significant figure” in the party, but he said people in the party were entitled to hold different views.
Polanski says it's 'absurd' to say 'Zionism is racism' motion antisemitic
Asked about claims from the Board of Deputies of British Jews and others that the motion was anti-Jewish, Polanksi replied:
I think that’s absurd. And I think it’s actually dangerous rhetoric, because we really need to separate antisemitism from criticism of the Israeli government.
I say that as a Jewish man, but actually the co-composer of this motion was a Holocaust survivor.
So I think we do need to respect that there’s a diversity of opinion amongst the Jewish communities.
Polanski says he agrees with 'substance' of Green 'Zionism is racism' motion, but not actual wording passed at conference
On Sky News, Sam Coates, the deputy political editor, said the Green vote in the Holborn and St Pancras byelection was broadly the same as it had been in the constituency in the local elections in May. He put it to Zack Polanski that this showed there was no evidence that Polanski was bringing “electoral stardust” to the campaign.
Polanski said he had been party leader at the time of the May elections. And he claimed that, in the campaign, he felt people were “very excited” by his campaign.
He also said the Greens had achieved their two best byelection results ever under his leadership.
Asked if he accepted the Green party conference vote for the “Zionism is racism” motion had been disastrous for the party, he replied:
I think what this demonstrated is that we do politics differently to the other parties. In other parties, [the] leadership decide the policy. They decide how everything goes.
Polanski said Labour deliberately chose to hold the byelection a few days after the Green party’s conference.
Asked if he regretted the fact that the “Zionism is racism” motion was passed, he replied:
I grew up in a Zionist household. I grew up with this idea of a land without people, a people without a land [the Zionist argument that, when Jews moved to Israel to found a state, there was no one else living there.]
But in recent years I’ve been discovering what happened to those people in the land. They were displaced. And at the moment there’s a genocide that our government is not just complicit in, but actively selling arms licenses to.
And so I think that is a racist ideology.
Asked if he supported the motion, Polanski said:
I would have supported the motion as amended. It wasn’t amended. So no.
Ultimately I agree with the substance of the motion. Where I disagree is the idea the Green party should be deciding what the future of the region looks like.
Updated
Polanski says Greens have succeeded in making Labour shift to left - but predicts voters will soon feel 'duped'
When it was put to Polanski on Sky News that polling shows that the Green party is less popular now than it was (see 6.31am), Polanski offered this explanation. He said:
Let’s look at why the popularity has waned. I would say it’s because people voted Green and then we moved Labour.
In fact, at the May local elections, four times as many votes went to the Green party as they did to Reform. I always said that part of my mission was to make the Labour government more worried about the Green party than Reform. Mission achieved.
We’ve now got a different prime minister who is in a honeymoon, who is talking a lot of the language I’ve been talking about for the past year. So I see that as a result.
The real question now – and no one knows the answer to this – is does Andy Burnham really want to end neoliberalism? And if he does, why has he ruled out rent controls? Why is he talking about public control of water companies rather than national ownership?
What we’re hearing is rhetoric. We’re not yet seeing action.
If there is action, I’ll be the first to applaud him.
But I suspect very quickly people will feel like they’ve been duped by this Labour government.
Polanski says claims byelection result shows his popularity sinking are 'overblown'
Asked if it was a mistake to stand as the party’s candidate, given that he lost, Polanski told Sky News:
Not in the slightest. I think it was a really good opportunity to get back on track, talking about the things we really need to be talking about: rent controls, nationalising Thames Water, keeping oil and gas in the ground.
These were all on the ballot paper.
And actually Sagal [Abdi-Wali], who’s now the MP, she’s pledged to oppose new oil and gas. She’s pledged to nationalise Thames Water or to push for [the] prime minister to nationalise Thames Water.
People have told me they want to give Andy Burnham a chance. He’s got a chance now.
He also claimed that he had turned a safe Labour seat into a marginal Labour/Green seat.
He went on:
I think the idea that this is some shine coming off me, or some difficulty, I think is overblown.
Polanski says he's achieved Green party's second best ever byelection result
Zack Polanski has also been on Sky News. This is what he said explaining why he thought it was a good result for his party.
We tripled our vote share in this election. And John Curtis this morning has said that this seat demonstrates that we are going to be more of an electoral threat to Labour than we ever have [been] in our history. [See 6.31am.]
This was our second best ever byelection result in history, so of course I wanted to win it. We didn’t win it, we didn’t do enough. But it’s still it’s a huge momentum.
Polanski says Green party's 'Zionism is racism' motion 'imperfect', but he would have voted for amended version
On BBC Breakfast, asked if he supported the “Zionism is racism” motion passed at the Green party conference on Sunday, Polanski said that he “grew up in a Zionist household” but now understood the impact this had had on Palestinians. He said:
It’s very obvious to me that if there is an ongoing genocide, then that is underpinned by a racist ideology.
Asked if he agreed with the motion that was passed, Polanski said that he agreed with some parts of it, but that it was “imperfect” and he disagreed with other bits.
He said he agreed that the “displacement and genocide” of the Palestinian people was underpinned by a “racist ideology”. But he said he did not agree the British government should push for a single state solution.
If he had been at the conference, he would have voted to amend the motion, he said.
Polanski claims Holborn and St Pancras result shows Greens 'more of a threat' to Labour than before
Zack Polanski is doing a media interview round this morning.
Speaking to BBC Breakfast, he said he was “incredibly proud” of the campaign he ran in Holborn and St Pancras and he said it showed the Greens were “more of an electoral threat in [Labour] seats than we’ve ever been before”. That was a “foundation we’re looking to build on”, he said.
Green party's claim its vote share up 22% in Holborn and St Pancras misleading, polling expert says
As Bridget Phillipson prepares for her media round (see 6.34am), she may be reading this post by Peter Kellner on his Substack blog. Kellner, a former president of YouGov and a leading polling expert, argues that this is not just a standard byelection win for Labour in a safe seat, but instead a historic win for the party. And he says that it is misleading for the Greens to claim they have had a great result on the basis of their vote share rising by 22%. (See 4.23am.)
Kellner explains:
Last night [Polanski’s] team crowed that the Greens had trebled their share of the vote. This is an example of “paltering”, a useful, underused word for a statement that is technically correct but seriously misleading. I wrote about this last year, with Labour and Conservative examples of this shoddy practice.
The Greens can make their “trebling” claim only because the left-wing vote two years ago was divided between the Greens’ 10.4 per cent and an independent, Andrew Feinstein’s, 18.9 per cent. Together, they won 29.3 per cent. Feinstein stood aside this time to support Polanski, who won 32.8 per cent: a true increase of just 3.5 percentage points.
That’s not all. The same issue arose in Gorton & Denton in February. There, George Galloway’s Workers Party stood aside, having won 10.3 per cent two years ago. So the combined Green/Workers baseline was 23.5 per cent. In the by-election, the Greens’ Hannah Spencer won 40.7 per cent, a hefty 17.2 point increase on the combined left-wing share in 2024.
Kellner has this chart illustrating his point.
Kellner also points out that, when Hannah Spencer won Gorton and Denton for the Greens in February, the total number of people voting for her as the Green/left was up by more than 6,000 on the equivalent vote at the general election. That was a sign her campaign had generated huge enthusiasm. In Holborn and St Pancras, the overall Green/left vote was down by more than 2,000 on the 2024 result.
Kellner points out that Polanski’s personal approval ratings have fallen sharply over the past eight months, and he says this byelection is only the 10th when Labour has been in government and defending a seat in a byelection with the main opposition coming not from the right but from either the Lib Dems or the Greens. He says Sagal Abdi-Wali’s share of the vote fell by just 3.7 percentage points – which was less than in any of those other contests.
There is more in Kellner’s analysis, which is well worth reading in full.
And here is his take on how significant this is.
Only three times in the party’s history has a Labour government been able to cheer a by-election night as a boost to its prospects of remaining in office.
The first was retaining Kingston-upon-Hull North in January 1966, ahead of its big national victory two months later. The second was four months ago, when Andy Burnham won Makerfield (though some ministers were happier than others).
The third was last night.
Here is Bridget Phillipson, the Labour party chair, commenting on the byelection result on Bluesky.
The best news to wake up to ahead of the morning round.
Congratulations to Sagal, who has led such a positive campaign. Thank you to the brilliant Labour team and members who made this win possible.
Britain is backing Labour’s message of hope.
“Morning round” means she is giving interviews later.
Prof Sir John Curtice, the BBC’s lead elections expert, has said the Holborn and St Pancras byelection result reflects what is happening in national opinion polls. He said:
Labour are in a much better position than they were six months ago, but they are still not as popular as they were in 2025, and holding a general election now would look an extremely risky project for them.
But [the result] also indicates that the Greens, while, yes, a more significant player than historically they have ever been, they have lost a significant portion of the ground that they had managed to gain during the first year of Zack Polanski’s leadership.
This chart, from Politico’s Poll of Polls, illustrates Curtice’s point. Nationally, the Greens are polling at about 10% – which is broadly where they were before Polanski became leader in September last year.
Full results in Holborn and St Pancras byelection
Good morning. I’m Andrew Sparrow, taking over from Hamish Mackay.
Here are the full results for the byelection, including vote share and how it has changed since the general election, plus the results from 2024. The figures are from the Press Association.
Sagal Abdi-Wali (Lab) 12,292 (45.17%, -3.75%)
Zack Polanski (Green) 8,928 (32.81%, +22.37%)
Ewan Cameron (C) 1,922 (7.06%, -0.13%)
Peter Newman (Reform) 1,612 (5.92%, -0.22%)
Patrick Stillman (LD) 924 (3.40%, -2.40%)
Tyler Johnson (Restore) 692 (2.54%)
George Galloway (WPB) 314 (1.15%)
Briony Kapoor (Rejoin) 236 (0.87%)
Barmy Brunch (Loony) 87 (0.32%, -0.10%)
Helen Spiby-Vann (CPA) 63 (0.23%)
Clare Fischer (Climate) 51 (0.19%)
Ben Walker (UKIP) 51 (0.19%, -0.01%)
Ketankumar Pipaliya (Voice) 23 (0.08%)
Jonathan Silberman (Comm Lge) 9 (0.03%)
Tom Darwood (ND) 7 (0.03%, -18.92%)
Lab maj 3,364 (12.36%)
13.06% swing Lab to Green
Electorate 70,449; Turnout 27,211 (38.63%, -15.52%)
2024: Lab maj 11,572 (29.98%) – Turnout 38,602 (54.14%)
Starmer (Lab) 18,884 (48.92%); Feinstein (ND) 7,312 (18.94%);
Stansell (Green) 4,030 (10.44%); Malik (C) 2,776 (7.19%); Roberts
(Reform) 2,371 (6.14%); Clinton (LD) 2,236 (5.79%); Islam (Ind) 636
(1.65%); Brick (Loony) 162 (0.42%); Poynton (UKIP) 75 (0.19%);
Scripps (Soc Eq) 61 (0.16%); Kumar (Ind) 40 (0.10%); Smith (ND) 19
(0.05%)
Sagal Abdi-Wali, Zack Polanski and the other candidates have now left the count. Here are some of the latest images from Holborn and St Pancras:
Speaking to the Guardian after her win, Abdi-Wali said local people at the school gates found the Greens’ Zionism motion “divisive”, adding:
It just speaks to the larger divisive discourse that set off and I don’t want to engage in that kind of thing.
On Labour’s stance on Palestine, she said:
The work Ed Miliband has been doing on Gaza, Palestine and Israel has resonated really well with local people. He’s been taking action and not just speaking.
Asked after the result whether he believed Zionism was racism, Polanski said he “grew up in a Zionist household” with the “idea that region was a land without a people and a people without a land”. But he said after educating himself he doesn’t “believe that’s true, and what we’re seeing is an ongoing genocide and the displacement of the Palestinian people. I believe that’s clearly racist.”
Polanski sidesteps question about whether he thinks Zionism is racism
Ahead of the vote, former Green leader Caroline Lucas suggested Polanski could face a threat to his leadership if he lost.
Lucas, the three-time former Green Party leader who was its first MP, said people should “see what happens in the coming days and weeks” when asked about his future the previous evening on BBC Newsnight. (See 2.55am.)
She pointed to Polanski’s failure to take part in the controversial anti-Zionism motion on Sunday, saying he “should have been there and he should have voted”.
Polanski did not directly answer when asked if he believed that Zionism is racism after the by-election result, but said:
The displacement of the Palestinian people, the genocide is clearly racist.
He also denied he had lost control of his party.
I don’t think that’s true at all. I’ve got a party that was 55,000, 60,000 members when I was running for leader, it’s now 220,000.
Any member is entitled to their opinion. We’re a democratic grassroots party.
Updated
We’ve got a bit from Polanski on his future after the defeat.
He told PA:
Of course I can carry on as leader of the Green Party. Of course, I wanted to win. No-one runs an election to lose.
Of course, we didn’t get over the line, but the point here is that ultimately, I want to make sure those were the options that people have.
So many people told me on the doorstep, so they want to give Andy Burnham a chance. Well, he’s got a chance now. Let’s see what he does with it.
Result is victory for diversity that cannot be 'casually undone', says Abdi-Wali
New Labour MP Sagal Abdi-Wali said her win in the Holborn and St Pancras byelection was a victory for diversity and warned cohesion should not be “casually undone”.
Her comments came after Reform UK’s home affairs spokesperson Zia Yusuf attacked her candidacy as a British-Somalian shortly after the byelection was called.
Abdi-Wali said she hoped “people like (her)” would feel like they also “belong here”.
Speaking after her victory was announced in Camden council’s headquarters in north London, she said:
I hope this moment also says something about who gets to belong, for people who look like me, I hope they see themselves reflected in this place and know that their path too belongs here. This is Camden, and this is Britain.
We have a responsibility to defend what we’ve built, and pass it on. Hope is not naive. Without hope there is nothing to build on, and nothing to build for.
People need to believe that politics can make their lives better and that their communities can thrive and that tomorrow can be better than today.”
The Holborn and St Pancras turnout of 38.76% is lower than in some other recent byelections, including 47.62% at Gorton and Denton in February.
At that one, Hannah Spencer won for the Green party and took the seat from Labour.
There was 58.7% turnout at the Makerfield byelection in June that paved Andy Burnham’s way to become prime minister. And it was 44.37% in Clacton in August, when Nigel Farage kept his seat but Count Binface took more than a quarter of the vote.
Here’s a full rundown on the byelection results – sorted alphabetically – and who the votes went to.
Sagal Abdi-Wali (Labour) – 12,292
Barmy Brunch (Monster Raving Loony party) – 87
Ewan Cameron (Conservative party) – 1,922
Tom Darwood (independent) – 7
Claire Fischer (Climate party) – 51
George Galloway (Workers’ party) – 314
Tyler Kurtis (Restore) – 692
Briony Kapoor (Rejoin EU) – 236
Peter Newman (Reform UK) – 1,612
Ketankumar Pipaliya (UK Voice) – 23
Zack Polanski (Green party) – 8,928
Jonathan Silberman (Communist League) – 9
Helen Spiby-Vann (Christian Peoples Alliance) – 63
Patrick Stillman (Liberal Democrats) – 924
Ben Walker (Ukip) – 51
PA Media
Updated
Green party says 22% rise in vote share 'incredible result' for Polanski in safe Labour seat
While Zack Polanski has vowed to stay on as Greens leader, the party put a bright spin on what it called an “incredible result” with the increased vote share he brought the party in the byelection.
“Achieving a huge swing in one of Labour’s safest seats – an increase of 22% in vote share since the general election – is an incredible result for the Green party, and during a honeymoon period for the new PM,” a Greens spokesperson quoted by PA Media said.
We are disappointed to miss out tonight but any ideas of a return to the cosy two-party system is just wishful thinking on the part of the establishment. We are here to stay and just getting started.
The voters have delivered a message to the Labour government today. They want real change.
Updated
Polanski 'absolutely' intends to remain Greens leader
Zack Polanski has said he definitely intends to stay on as leader of the Greens despite his byelection defeat.
Asked on Sky News if he would continue as party leader, he said: “Yes absolutely, that’s what leaders do.”
He also said after the poll result that it had not been a mistake standing in the north London seat, saying he was happy to stand in elections.
I don’t think it was a mistake at all, I think it has been an opportunity to present Green party values, to talk about rent controls, tackling the climate crisis, nationalising Thames Water. It’s been amazing to speak to people in Holborn and St Pancras, I’ve really enjoyed that.
Updated
Labour wins byelection after Greens fall short
Here’s a fuller rundown on Labour’s win in the Holborn and St Pancras byelection that has been a high-stakes battle for the left of British politics.
The byelection, called after the former prime minister Keir Starmer resigned from the seat in September, was considered a two-horse race between the Labour candidate, Sagal Abdi-Wali, and the Green party leader, Zack Polanski.
Abdi-Wali recieved 12,292 votes to Polanski’s 8,928, Sammy Gecsoyler reports.
Turnout was 38.7%, the lowest for any byelection held in England during this parliament and 15.4% down from 2024.
The Greens conceded defeat shortly before the result was announced, with a party spokesperson saying “taking the fight to Labour in one of its safest seats shows just how far the Greens have come”.
Labour’s victory will be a relief for Andy Burnham in his first big electoral test as prime minister, and reinforces polling that shows he has recovered some public support lost by Starmer, his predecessor in Downing Street.
See the full report here:
Updated
Labour campaigned hard in this byelection, fielding the 42-year-old leader of Camden council as the party’s candidate. Sagal Abdi-Wali arrived in London in the early 90s – speaking no English – after fleeing war in Somalia with her four brothers and her mother, who trained as a lawyer in Somalia.
In a pre-poll message to byelection voters, prime minister Andy Burnham said:
This area gave Sagal a home when she arrived here as a refugee in the 1990s. Camden gave Sagal and her family hope. Now she wants to give that back to the communities that have always been there for her. It’s hard to think of someone more committed to their local area and the care of people than Sagal.
Abdi-Wali says byelection win 'deeply personal to me'
Returning to Sagal Abdi-Wali’s acceptance speech, the newly elected Labour MP said that whether people voted for her or not, “I promise that I will work every day to do whatever I can and all I can to improve your life”.
This moment means something deeply personal to me – to represent the place that gave me a home, and my family a home, gave me opportunity and helped shape the person I am today.
Camden gave me a community and instilled in me a belief in social justice, in equality and in fairness. And to now have the privilege of representing this same community in parliament is something that I will carry with enormous pride and humility.
I hope this moment also says something about who gets to belong. For people who look like me, I hope they see themselves reflected in this place, and know that their path too belongs here.
This is Camden, and this is Britain.
Updated
Sagal Abdi-Wali is speaking and saying she is “deeply honoured” to be chosen by her constituency and that her commitment to it “runs deep”.
From the bottom of my heart I want to say thank you.
More soon.
Updated
Labour declared byelection winner
Labour’s Sagal Abdi-Wali has been declared the byelection winner with 12,292 votes. Zack Polanski came in second for the Greens with 8,928, while the Conservatives’ Ewan Cameron polled third with 1,922.
Updated
The byelection candidates have gathered in the vote tally room at Camden Council headquarters in north London and it appears a declaration of the results is imminent.
Caroline Lucas says Polanski should have voted in Green party Zionism debate
Circling back to Caroline Lucas, the former Green party leader said shortly after the byelection polls closed that Zack Polanski had made a “mistake not to show leadership” over the Zionism policy vote, but she declined to say if he should resign over it.
“He should have been there and he should have voted,” she told BBC Newsnight.
I would’ve hoped that he would have really been a very strong critic of this motion, because the motion was flawed from top to bottom, in my view.
Lucas said she expected he would face a lot criticism from fellow Greens now the byelection was over. But asked if he should resign, she said:
I think let’s just see what happens in the coming days and weeks ... obviously he has been completed taken up with this byelection. I want him to speak now about what’s happened, I want him to show the leadership that was frankly missing on Sunday. I think the jury is out about whether or not he will do that but I very much hope he will.
Updated
Activists in Camden have suggested the Greens’ decision to back the anti-Zionism motion has cost them votes in the byelection.
Councillors for both Labour the Liberal Democrats told the Press Association that voters had informed them they would not be backing the Green party after it passed the motion last weekend calling Zionism racism.
One councillor said people had been “clearly angry” about the issue when they had spoken to them while canvassing.
Greens concede byelection defeat
The Greens have conceded defeat in the Holborn and St Pancras byelection, saying they have come a “close second” in the contest.
A party spokesperson said:
It is clear now we will come a close second in this by-election. Taking the fight to Labour in one of its safest seats shows just how far the Greens have come.
Voters want us to keep Labour’s feet to the fire on affordable housing, public ownership of water and the climate crisis. Greens will be there every single day, holding Labour to account and demanding the change people voted for.
The loss will be disappointing for Zack Polanski, who was hoping to replicate the party’s seismic win in Gordon and Denton earlier this year. Thousands of party activists descended on the north London constituency to knock doors but it appears their efforts fell short.
The results caps off a bruising week Polanski and his eco-populist party, which fell into turmoil after it voted on Sunday to adopt a policy declaring Zionism as a form of racism, sparking internal division that continued after polls closed. Former party leader Caroline Lucas refused to say whether Polanski should stand down within an hour of polls shutting while speaking to BBC Newsnight.
Updated
The Greens have conceded defeat in the Holborn and St Pancras byelection.
A party spokesperson is quoted as saying: “It is clear now we will come a close second.”
More details soon.
Updated
Party officials are gathering as the result is expected imminently.
From the count here in Camden council’s swanky headquarters, signs suggest a Labour-win is imminent.
After the polls closed, the Greens issued a fairly downbeat statement on the “positive campaign” the party ran in “what is one of Labour’s safest seats” – hardly a barnstorming comment suggesting confidence in their chances tonight.
A Green loss could spell further disquiet in the party after a motion terming Zionism as a form of racism passed at its conference. Shortly after polls closed, former Caroline Lucas refused to say whether Polanski should stand down.
Speaking to BBC Newsnight, the former Green leader said: “I want him to show the leadership that was frankly missing on Sunday,” when the motion was voted on. Polanski was campaigning in the constituency instead.
Turnout is 38.7%, the lowest for any byelection held in England during this parliament and 15.4% down from 2024.
Updated
Inside the vote counting room – in pictures
Green party leader Zack Polanski has been seen arriving at Camden Council chambers in north London as the byelection count continues. Here are some scenes from the room.
Updated
Zack Polanski’s had a tricky week leading up to the byelection amid criticism he showed a lack of leadership over a policy equating Zionism with racism adopted at last weekend’s Green party conference
Polanski missed the vote on it in Brighton in order to campaign in the Holborn and St Pancras byelection.
But the Greens’ adoption of the policy has been highly contentious – drawing sharp rebukes from mainstream UK parties, British Jewish groups and Israel – while also prompting four of five Green MPs to publicly reject the move.
The motion said Zionism – the movement for a Jewish state – should be “treated as any other form of racism” and called for Israel to be replaced by a single Palestinian state. The head of the Jewish Greens condemned it and said she might leave the party, although it was supported by some Jewish Greens.
Even members who supported large parts of the motion were unhappy about its narrow conception of Zionism which some fear could brand those in favour of the idea of a Jewish homeland – but not specifically the modern-day state of Israel – as racist.
The English and Welsh Greens are facing international ostracism after their adoption of the policy drew dismay from the group representing European Greens.
Who are the candidates?
A quick reminder of the byelection candidates in Holborn and St Pancras:
-
Labour – Sagal Abdi-Wali
-
Green party – Zack Polanski
-
Conservative party – Ewan Cameron
-
Reform UK – Peter Newman
-
Liberal Democrats – Patrick Thomas Stillman
-
Restore Britain – Tyler Kurtis Johnson
-
Workers party – George Galloway
-
Rejoin EU – Briony Anne Lonbay Kapoor
-
Climate party – Clare Fischer
-
UK Voice – Ketankumar Pipaliya
-
Ukip – Ben Walker
-
Monster Raving Loony party – Barmy Brunch
-
Communist League – Jonathan Silberman
-
Christian Peoples Alliance – Helen Spiby-Vann
-
Independent – Tom Darwood
Updated
Holborn and St Pancras is, under normal circumstances, a Labour stronghold.
Keir Starmer won it with a majority of 11,500 at the 2024 general election despite strong challenges from the Greens and a leftwing independent candidate, who is not standing again and has endorsed Zack Polanski. In 2019 Starmer won by nearly 28,000 votes.
Polanski has run a highly energetic campaign. He has mobilised a large numbers of supporters to knock on doors, mimicking February’s Gorton and Denton byelection, where the Greens overcame an even bigger Labour majority to take the seat.
However, the political landscape has changed. Shortly after Gorton and Denton, YouGov polling put the Greens briefly above Labour, on a peak of 21%. The most recent equivalent had Polanksi’s party on 11%, 16 points behind Labour.
Burnham, who succeeded Starmer as prime minister in July, is seen as having revitalised Labour, and used his speech at the party’s annual conference last month to set out a more ambitious and left-leaning collection of policies.
Polanski’s fortunes, in contrast, appear to have declined, especially since last weekend’s Green party conference where a vote by members to adopt a policy equating Zionism with racism and calling for Israel to be replaced by a single Palestinian state prompted condemnation and splits in the party.
Counting under way in Holborn and St Pancras byelection
Hello and welcome to the UK politics live blog.
Counting is currently under way in the Holborn and St Pancras byelection in north London, where voters are choosing a replacement for former prime minister Sir Keir Starmer.
Starmer announced his decision to step down as an MP in September after being ousted from No 10 by Andy Burnham.
Camden council has said the result is expected to be called between 2:30-4am UK time.
We’ll bring you the latest developments as we get them.