Andrew Sparrow 

Macron tells UK parliament that Europe must end its dependency on the US and China – UK politics live

The French president is addressing parliament on the first day of his state visit to the UK
  
  

France's President Emmanuel Macron and his wife Brigitte Macron.
France's President Emmanuel Macron and his wife Brigitte Macron. Photograph: Ludovic Marin/AFP/Getty Images

Macron confirms the Bayeux Tapestry announcement, which gets a loud round of applause.

He thanks King Charles for his hospitality. And he ends:

Finally, we meet again, and let’s be sure that we will meet again for years and decades, because we are linked by our geography, by our past, but we are linked by our common future.

And the only way to overcome the challenges we have, the challenges for our times, would be to go together, hand in hand, shoulder to shoulder.

Macron gets a standing ovation.

Macron suggests new rules are needed to protect children in Europe from the dangers social media.

Macron: Europe must end excessive dependencies on both the US and China

Macron says European countries must end their “excessive dependencies on both the US and China”.

He suggests China’s use of subsidies are a threat to fair trade.

And he says that President Trump’s trade war is also an attack on WTO rules.

He says the European democratic model is as under threat from “foreign interference, information manipulation, domination of minds by negative emotions and addictions to social media”.

Updated

Macron says he is the first EU head of state to make a state visit since Brexit.

And he praises Starmer for restoring trust in that relationship.

Macron says UK and France have duty to tackle illegal migration 'with humanity, solidarity and firmness'

Macron says the UK and France also work together on the climate.

And the two countries will cooperate to tackle illegal migration, he says.

We cannot allow our countries’ rules for taking in people to be flouted in criminal networks, to cynically exploit the hopes of so many individuals with so little respect for human life.

France and the United Kingdom have a shared responsibility to address irregular migration with humanity, solidarity and firmness.

The decisions that we will take at our bilateral summit will respond to our aims for cooperation and tangible results on these major issues.

Very clearly, we task our minister of domestic affairs [Home Office ministers, in UK terms] to work very closely together, and I want to salute the very close coordination and cooperation.

But Macron also says there will only be “a lasting and effective solution” with action at the European level.

Macon says UK and France have 'special responsibility' for security of Europe

Macron says the UK-France pact on defence and security is getting stronger.

And he says he and Keir Starmer will take this further at their summit this week.

There is an expectation in Europe that the two countries have “a special responsibility for the security of the continent”, he says.

UPDATE: Macron said:

Our two countries, the only European nuclear weapon states, the leading armed forces of the continent, together accounting for 40% of European military budgets, both fully shoulder the responsibility when it comes to European security.

And we are faced with new threats, with aggressive nuclear powers, with sometimes hesitating alliances, and the return of major conflict on our continent. This is why, in two days, our summit is so important, and the announcement we prepared so historical.

Macron said there was an expectation that the UK and France, “faced with revisionist neighbours” have a “special responsibility for the security of the continent”.

And he said, to paraphrase William Pitt, it was time to “make sure that not only our two countries will save themselves by their own exertions, but also that we will save Europe by our example and our solidarity”.

Pitt said: “England has saved herself by her exertions, and will, as I trust, save Europe by her example.”

Updated

Macron says the UK and France cannot tolerate the threat that would be posed by Iran having a nuclear weapon. They will work for a deal “which ensures international monitoring of Iran’s nuclear programme over the long term, thereby preserving the international non-proliferation framework as a foundation for collective security”.

Macron calls for ceasefire in Gaza, saying 'dehumunisation' happening there cannot be justified

Macron says the UK and France are calling for a ceasefire in Gaza.

It is a matter of absolute urgency to end the suffering of the hostages and of the Gazans.

A war without end and without a strategic objective poses a huge threat to the region and our collective security.

Today, a dehumanisation is occurring there that can never be justified together.

We are aware that the political way out is crucial, and I believe in the future of the two-state solution as a basis for regional security architecture, which will enable Israel to live in peace and security alongside its neighbours.

But I want to be clear: calling today for a ceasefire in Gaza without any conditions is just telling to the rest of the world that for us, as Europeans, there is no double standard.

Macron says Europeans will never abandon Ukraine

Macron says, as permanent members of the UN security council, the UK and France are “deeply committed to multilateralism, the United Kingdom and France must once again show the world that our alliance can make all the difference”.

He says the two countries have to defend multilaterism and protect the international order.

Turning to Ukraine, he says:

Together we worked very hard during the past few years in order to stand with the Ukrainian people, just helping them to resist.

We were right, and we are right, and because every time Vladimir Putin’s Russia advances in Ukraine, the threat moves closer to us all.

We will never accept the theory that might is right. And I want to be clear, this is why, together with you, Mr Prime Minister, we decided to launch last February this coalition. And this coalition was just a signal that Europeans will never abandon Ukraine, never.

And whatever the decisions could be elsewhere, we will fight till the very last minute in order to get the ceasefire, in order to start the negotiations to build this robust and sustainable peace, because this is our security and our principles together which are at stake in Ukraine.

Macron says democracies now under attack 'on daily basis'

Macron says the French will never forgot the sacrifice the British people made during the war.

The French people shall never forget the sacrifices British people made to protect Europe and the world during the two world wars and to uphold, with fierce determination, the promise of our entente cordiale.

We shall never forget the support of the asylum your forefathers gave to the Free French forces in the fight against the barbarism of the Nazis.

Churchill was a visionary, who believed in “a strong transatlantic alliance” and “a peaceful European order”. He goes on:

[Churchill] passed the same vision onto us of a world order based on law, justice and respect for territorial integrity – an order that is today being attacked on a daily basis as we witness direct attacks on our democracies, the return of war to our continent, the resurgence of imperial impulses and the flouting of international rules by destabilising powers while attempting to divide up the world to their advantage.

Updated

Macron pays tribute to Starmer, saying he was the first British prime minister to attend an Armistice Day celeberation in Paris in 80 years. Thank you, he says.

President Macron is speaking in French, and he starts by thanking his hosts. It is a very great honour to speak before both Houses of Parliament, he says.

He says parliament is a place where “modern democracy emerged”.

In France Rousseau was inspired by Locke, he says.

(We are a long way now from rugby league.)

He goes on:

Please do not misunderstand me. I’m not going so far as to say that England gave birth to the French Revolution.

However, I have to confess that we love monarchy, but especially when it’s not our own.

Hoyle is now winding up.

Macron takes to the podium.

Hoyle talks about Britain and France fighting together in the second world war.

And he recalls President Zelenskyy visiting parliament. France and the UK are both part of the “Coalition of the Willing” to support Ukraine.

Hoyle says the first ever foreign dignitary to address parliament was a French president.

And 100 years ago France and Britain were both founding members of the parliamentary union, he says.

Hoyle is now talking about sporting links between the two countries. He says he wants to praise in particular the French rugby league (rugby league is a passion of his, he says).

(Quite what Macron makes about this tribute to the Catalan Dragons is not clear. Hoyle is now going on about how they once beat his team, Warrington.)

Lindsay Hoyle, the Commons Speaker, is introducing the president.

He points out that the French language is embedded in the way parliament works. Parliament itself comes from a French word, (parler), he works with a dossier every day, and when laws are passed, that is announced in Norman French.

President Macron is entering the Royal Gallery. MPs and peers are applauding.

President Macron is running late, so here is a chance to have a look at the Bayeux Tapestry.

Here is more from the Department for Culture, Media and Sport on the Bayeux Tapestry loan.

The loan will form part of a bilateral season of culture in 2027 that will celebrate the 1000th anniversary of the birth of William the Conquerer and the Grand Départ of the 2027 Tour de France from the UK.

Lord Peter Ricketts has been appointed by the government to act as the UK Government’s Envoy for the Bayeux Tapestry Loan. Further details on the loan of the Bayeux Tapestry, the loan of the Sutton Hoo Treasure will be made in due course.

In addition, three UK cultural organisations will also be signing Memoranda of Understanding with French counterparts: the British Film Institute and the Centre National du Cinema; the National Trust and the Centre des Monuments Nationaux; and Sadler’s Wells and the Chaillot Théâtre National de la Danse. These partnerships between some of our flagship cultural organisations will ensure that creative partnerships and projects can continue to thrive between our two nations for years to come.

British Museum director says Bayeux Tapestry loan is 'exactly kind of international partnership' museum should champion

In a comment on the Bayeux Tapestry loan (see 4.18pm), Nicholas Cullinan, director of the British Museum, said:

This will be the first time the Bayeux Tapestry has been in the UK since it was made, almost 1000 years ago. We are also delighted to send the Lewis chessmen, and some of our treasures from Sutton Hoo - the greatest archaeological discovery in Britain – to France in return.

This is exactly the kind of international partnership that I want us to champion and take part in: sharing the best of our collection as widely as possible – and in return displaying global treasures never seen here before.

That final sentence may alarm people who are alarmed by reports that the museum is planning to send the Parthenon Marbles to Athens on a long-term loan.

Updated

Bayeux Tapestry to go on display in UK for 11 months from next autumn, Starmer and Macron announce

The UK government has just announced that Keir Starmer and President Macron have agreed for the Bayeux Tapestry to go on display in the UK from next autumn. In a news release, the culture department says:

The loan, which will mark the first time the Bayeux Tapestry has been in the UK in nearly 1,000 years, will be displayed in the The Sainsbury Exhibitions Gallery of the British Museum in London between September 2026 and July 2027.

It is expected that the blockbuster exhibition, which will offer the chance to see the Tapestry up close for the first time on UK soil since its creation, will also boost London’s visitor economy.

The 70-metre work, which is more than 900-year-old, depicts the 1066 Norman invasion and Battle of Hastings. The battle saw William the Conquerer take the English throne from Harald Godwinson and become the first Norman King of England. It is widely accepted to have been made in England during the 11th century and was likely to have been commissioned by Bishop Odo of Bayeux. The Tapestry has been on display in various locations in France throughout its history, including most recently at the Bayeux Museum.

In addition to the loan of the Bayeux Tapestry, the British Museum will loan the Sutton Hoo collection, the Lewis Chessmen and other treasures to France. The Sutton Hoo treasures, discovered as part of a seventh century Anglo-Saxon ship burial in Suffolk in 1939, provide remarkable insights into England from a time before the Norman Conquest. Museums in Normandy will host the Sutton Hoo treasures while they are in France.

There was a similar announcement in 2018 – but that visit never materialised.

Macron’s speech to parliament will be “very powerful and very symbolic”, Politico reports, quoting an Elysée Palace source.

MPs and peers have began to gather in Parliament’s Royal Gallery for an address by the French President, Emmanuel Macron, PA Media reports. PA says:

A platform with four chairs and a podium was erected in the southern end of the grand chamber, which features large murals of both the Battle of Trafalgar and the Battle of Waterloo, two great 19th century military defeats for the French at the hands of the British and their allies.

As they filed into the Royal Gallery, passing peers told members of press apocryphal stories that a previous French president requested the murals were covered during a past state visit.

Some peers attributed this to Charles de Gaulle, others to Jacques Chirac.

MPs sat on the right of the chamber facing the platform, while peers sat on the left.

President Macron to address parliament

President Macron will soon address MPs and peers in the Royal Gallery in the Houses of Parliament.

Earlier, on his arrival in the UK, Macron said:

The United Kingdom is a strategic partner, an ally, a friend. Our bond is longstanding, forged by history and strengthened by trust.

Together, we will address the major challenges of our time: security, defence, nuclear energy, space, innovation, artificial intelligence, migration, and culture.

These are all areas in which we seek to act together and deepen our co-operation in a concrete, effective and lasting way.

Lammy tells MPs UK will take further measures against Israel if ceasefire does not happen soon

David Lammy, the foreign secretary, has been giving evidence to the Commons foreign affairs committee. Here are some of the main points from the hearing.

  • Lammy said that the government would take further measures against Israel if a ceasefire does not happen soon. In response to a question from Labour’s Alex Ballinger, who said what was happening in Gaza was an “abomination”, Lammy said the government would take further action against the Israeli government if a ceasefire did not happen within weeks.

  • He refused to set a timeframe for when the UK would recognise Palestinian statehood, saying he could not “tie myself to a calendar because it’s convenient for a soundbite”. He said:

I’m not going to set it to a set timeframe, because I’ve explained that this is a moving, live situation. There are delicate ceasefire negotiations under way. I’ve explained the issues that sit within that, and whether we will get a… ceasefire. I’m hopeful that we will.

And alongside French and Saudi colleagues, we are discussing recognition, but my indication and my instinct is I actually want things to change the situation on the ground.

I don’t think I and the committee disagree with that, but there will be a judgment call, and I’m not going to tie myself to a calendar because it’s convenient for a soundbite. There’s a judgment call that, quite properly, you would expect the Government to think very hard about.

  • He said Britain, France and Germany could apply snapback sanctions on Iran if it tries to revive its ambitions for a nuclear weapon. He said:

Iran face even more pressure in the coming weeks because the E3 can snap back on our sanctions, and it’s not just our sanctions, it’s actually a UN mechanism that would impose dramatic sanctions on Iran across nearly every single front in its economy.

  • He claimed Keir Starmer’s embrace of the Volodymy Zelenskyy outside No 10 after the Ukrainian president’s difficult Oval Office meetinng with President Trump “calmed the nerves of the global community”. He explained:

I think after a very difficult meeting between President Trump and President Zelenskyy, I was hugely proud of our prime minister and I think you saw the strength of the relationship that the first place that President Zelensky came to was Number 10, and that embrace outside Number 10 I think also calmed the nerves of the global community frankly and the coalition of the willing was born out of that.

Labour says James McMurdock affair shows Reform UK can't be trusted to uphold 'high standards in public life'

Labour has said the James McMurdock affair show that Nigel Farage cannot be trusted to maintain high standards in public life. Commenting on McMurdock’s statement today (see 2.10pm), Ellie Reeves, the Labour chair, said:

After these serious allegations surfaced, Nigel Farage sat on his hands. He took no action against James McMurdock and instead outsourced the problem – that’s not leadership.

Reform has consistently claimed its vetting procedures are of the highest standards. Yet a man that was jailed for assaulting a woman and is now accused of ripping off taxpayers managed to slip through the net.

James McMurdock’s account of his own affairs doesn’t stack up. Nigel Farage must urgently come clean with the public about what he knew and when. Farage’s Reform has proven once again that they simply cannot uphold the high standards expected in public life.

Thomas says he is sympathetic to inquiry's call for permanent compensation body to be set up for scandals like this

Thomas told MPs that, if another scandal of this type were to happen, he hoped the victims would not need to bring a “traumatic court case” to expose it.

And he said there was another lesson for the future.

If such another scandal happens, government must be set up to offer trusted redress from the very start.

Sir Wyn [Williams] argues that there should be a standing public body to deliver redress in any further scandal. (See 1.18pm.)

I have a considerable amount of sympathy with that argument, but clearly we shall need to analyse the options fully before we commit to it.

The report says, in recommendation 17:

As soon as is reasonably practicable, HM Government shall establish a standing public body which shall, when called upon to do so, devise, administer and deliver schemes for providing financial redress to persons who have been wronged by public bodies.

Relatives of Post Office scandal victims to get compensation if they suffered, as inquiry recommends, MPs told

Thomas told MPs that the Post Office inquiry report showed how “blameless people were impoverished, bankrupted, stressed beyond beliefs, lost their jobs, their marriages, their reputations, their mental health, in some cases lost their lives” because of this scandal.

He said the government inherited a compensation scheme “which was widely seen as too slow, adversarial and legalistic”.

The government has now paid more almost £1.1bn in compensation, he said.

He said the government accepted the recommendation post office operators should be able to accept the best offer under the GLOS compensation scheme – without putting that at risk if go to the independent panel.

And he said the government accepted that compensation should be paid to relatives.

We will provide redress for family members of postmasters who suffered because of the scandal.

I have met the group Lost Chances for postmaster children who have campaigned with considerable courage on this issue.

Sir Wyn rightly recognises that designing a suitable compensation scheme for family members raises some very difficult issues.

Nonetheless, we want to look after those family members who suffered most, meeting Sir Wyn’s recommendation that we should give “redress to close family members of the most adversely affected by Horizon”.

Thomas said this scheme would be open to “close family members of existing Horizon claimants who themselves suffered personal injury, including psychological distress, because of their relative’s suffering”.

He said that, “other than in exceptional circumstances”, people would need to supply “contemporaneous and written evidence” of the injury they suffered.

Updated

Post Office minister Gareth Thomas says government 'very sympathetic' to inquiry's recommendations

In the Commons, Gareth Thomas, the business minister responsible for the Post Office, is making a statement about the report out today from the Post Office Horizon inquiry.

He says he is “very sympathetic” to the inquiry’s recommendations.

He says some will require “careful consideration”. But the government will respond to them by 10 October, as Sir Wyn Williams requested, he says. (See 12.47pm.)

Sats results for schools rise, but still have not reached pre-Covid levels, DfE figures show

The proportion of Year 6 pupils in England who met the expected standard in this year’s Sats exams has risen, but it is still below pre-pandemic levels, official statistics show.

As PA media reports, the key stage 2 results showed 62% of pupils reached the expected standard in reading, writing and maths combined this summer, up from 61% last year.

In 2019, 65% of pupils met the standard, according to the provisional Department for Education (DfE) data.

Teaching unions responded by restating calls for Sats to be abolished.

Daniel Kebede, general secretary of the National Educational Union, said:

NEU members tell us constantly that KS2 SATs narrow the curriculum and place unnecessary stress on many pupils, which school staff have to witness and mitigate against. We urge the government to scrap these harmful tests and view primary education as more than just this limited set of results.

And Paul Whiteman, general secretary of the NAHT school leaders’ union, said:

It is time to change this system of statutory assessment which is of little benefit to teachers or children. School leaders have told us loud and clear that Sats do very little to inform future teaching and learning, support children’s progress, or help their transition to secondary school. They tell teachers nothing they don’t already know from working day in and day out with pupils.

These tests are instead used as an accountability tool to judge and compare school performance – and not even a reliable one at that. They are given disproportionate significance and heap pressure onto pupils and staff, causing unnecessary stress and in some cases harming their wellbeing.

Rishi Sunak takes job with Goldman Sachs

Goldman Sachs has appointed former prime minister Rishi Sunak as a senior adviser, PA Media reports. PA says:

The role, which will see Sunak return to Goldman after 21 years, is his first major position since resigning as lead of the Conservative Party following its general election defeat last year.

Sunak, who was prime minister between October 2022 and July 2024, is set to advise leaders across the firm and provide “insights on the macroeconomic and geopolitical landscape”.

The MP for Richmond and Northallerton worked for Goldman Sachs between 2001 and 2004.

Chairman and chief executive David Solomon said: “I am excited to welcome Rishi back to Goldman Sachs in his new capacity as a senior advisor.

“In his role, he will work with leaders across the firm to advise our clients globally on a range of important topics, sharing his unique perspectives and insights on the macroeconomic and geopolitical landscape.

“He will also spend time with our people around the world, contributing to our culture of ongoing learning and development.”

James McMurdock says he no longer intends to return to Reform UK after inquiry into Covid loans concludes

James McMurdock has issued a statement saying that he will continue his parliamentary career as an independent MP, implying that he has given up any intention of returning to Reform UK.

Further to my statement tweeted on 5th July 2025. I have now had a chance to take specialist legal advice from an expert in the relevant field. In light of that advice, which is privileged and which I choose to keep private at this time, I have decided to continue my parliamentary career as an independent MP where I can focus 100% on the interests of my constituents.

McMurdock was one of five Reform UK MPs elected last July (he won South Basildon and East Thurrock with a majority of just 98). Rupert Lowe, another MP elected under the Reform banner at the election, has already left, meaning Nigel Farage has lost 40% of his 2024 intake (although he did gain another MP in a byelection, Sarah Pochin).

McMurdock’s departure was prompted by the publication of a report in the Sunday Timees saying that he took out two government loans, worth £70,000 in total, intended to help companies struggling during the Covid pandemic. McMurdock insisted the loans were lawful and proper, but the paper questioned whether the payments were appropriate given the size of the two companies, which did not have any employees.

On Saturday McMurdock said he was resigning the party whip pending an investigation into the allegations. He said he was doing that to protect the reputation of the party.

Today’s statement, which comes after Nigel Farage failed to defend him while on a visit yesterday, implies McMurdock’s relationship with Reform has now broken down.

Resident doctors in England vote to strike over pay

Resident doctors, formerly known as junior doctors, in England have voted in favour of strikes that could result in industrial action lasting until January next year, the British Medical Association has announced. Denis Campbell has the story.

Government announces 50 road and rail upgrades, including train link between Bristol and Portishead

Jamie Grierson is a senior Guardian reporter.

The West of England mayor was joined by political leaders at Bristol Temple Meads railway station today after plans to reopen the train line between the city and Portishead were given the green light as part of a wider package of transport investment announced by the government.

Metro mayor Helen Godwin, North Somerset MP Sadik Al-Hassan and council leaders were marking what is promised to be the final hurdle in the long-winded saga to reopen the line. Trains have not run between Portishead, a town of around 27,000, and Bristol for 60 years.

The government has pledged a further £27m towards the £150m project as part of a broader announcement of funding for road and rail projects across England.

The Department of Transport gave the go ahead overnight to more than 50 road and rail upgrades including the long awaited A66 Northern Trans-Pennine route.

Five major road schemes in the north and Midlands are confirmed as funded including the M54 to M6 link road in Staffordshire.

Three new train stations and funding a Midlands Rail Hub, creating brand new rail links for more than 50 locations, was also announced.

Speaking at Bristol Temple Meads, Labour MP for North Somerset, Al-Hassan, said the final investment for the Portishead line emerged from the spending review. He said:

The spending review is good governance for the nation’s finances. That’s money from the taxpayer being looked at, looking what is on what line, how we’re spending it. And that hasn’t been done for over a decade. So this is all possible because we actually looked at the books and looked where the money’s going, and got rid of things that didn’t need to be on there.

You may have noticed, the government has a priority on growth ... And if you’re looking for ways to do that, investments like the Portishead railway, increasing economic growth - an estimated £43m a year - that’s how you do it. So all of these projects that have been announced today is a commitment to growth on a regional and national level.

The Post Office Horizon IT inquiry has now published a seven-page summary of what today’s report says, and a press release version.

Williams says compensation should also be available to family members affected by Post Office scandal

Williams ended by saying that, when he started work on the inquiry, he was not familiar with the concept of restorative justice.

But, as the inquiry went on, calls for restorative justice became “louder and louder”, he said. He said the Post Office and Fujitsu embraced the concept “with what I might describe as varying degrees of enthusiasm”. He said he thought they would at least consider this approach. But nothing has happened. He urged the government to get involved.

He also said he thought compensation should be paid “to family members who have suffered serious adverse consequences as a result of the treatment meted out to their loved ones”.

Williams says he does not think victims, or the public, will ever accept that the conclusions of a redress scheme run by the organisation at fault are ever fully independent.

He says there is a case for setting up a compensation body which is truly independent to deal with cases like this.

But he says that could not happen quickly enough to be appropriate in this case.

He says there are more than 300 people who have been waiting more than five years for compensation in the HSS. It would be unfair to expect them to wait longer while a new system is set up, he says.

Williams says he agrees with the Commons business committee that the Horizon Shortfall Scheme (HSS) is the one in most need of improvement.

Williams says having four compensation schemes was mistake, and problems will persist even if recommendations adopted

Williams says, even if his recommendations are accepted in full, “they will not constitute some magic formula for removing all of the problems from which the [compensation] schemes suffer”.

He says he is critical of the Post Office and the government in relation to these schemes, “not least in relation to some of the egregious delays which have occurred”.

He says having four separate schemes was a mistake.

I cannot say plainly enough that there should not have been four distinct and separate schemes for delivering financial redress.

Updated

Williams is now talking about the Group Litigation Scheme (GLOS) – the scheme for post offfice operators who were part of the group legal case against the Post Office led by Alan Bates.

He says the claimants seemed to win “a famous victory” in court.

But the compensation they received under the deed of settlement “did not properly reflect their losses”, he says.

He says the last government agreed to increase the money available.

But some claimants still do not accept they are being offered full and fair compensation.

He goes on:

I would like to emphasise that a number of recommendations which I make are aimed at removing some of the obstacles which currently exist along the path to achieving settlements which are full and fair.

Even if the recommendations are accepted and implemented swiftly, however, it is difficult to imagine that the unresolved cases can be settled anytime soon.

I am loath to predict when all the claims in that scheme will be resolved, but I very much doubt whether settlements of every claim can be achieved before the end of next year … There are likely to be 150 claims or thereabouts in the process of assessment, which is a large number.

Williams says it is not obvious why two separate compensation schemes were set up for claimants whose convictions were quashed – one operated by the Post Office, and one operated by the government.

He is referring to the Overturned Convictions Scheme (OCS) and to the Horizon Conviction Redress Scheme (HCRS).

Williams questions fairness of some of compensation payments paid under Horizon Shortfall scheme

Williams is now going into more detail about his recommendations on compensation.

Under the Horizon Shortfall Scheme (HSS – one of the four compensation schemes), a “high percentage” of the most modest claims were settled by July 2024, he says. He goes on:

Whether some of those settlements were in reality full and fair can only be a matter of conjecture.

Williams says many of the claims in the £20,000 to £60,000 bracket were not settled on a “full and fair” basis.

And he says many of the larger claims have not been fully settled.

Updated

Williams says he wants government to say if it is accepting his recommendations within three months

Williams is now talking about compensation.

He quotes his first recommendation.

HM Government and/or the Department and where appropriate the Post Office and Fujitsu shall provide written responses to my recommendations by 10 October 2025.

He says some might see as this as a challenge to government. But it isn’t, he says. It is more of a “plea”.

He says three months should be enough for the government to decide whether or not it is accepting his recommendations.

He says, for the recommendations to have maximum affect, they must be accepted and implemented quickly.

Williams says evidence of human impact of Post Office scandal 'profoundly disturbing'

Williams says the picture in his report is “profoundly disturbing”. He goes on:

In summary, what does that picture reveal?

Many thousands of people have suffered serious financial detriment and for a sizeable proportion, that detriment subsists.

Many people have inevitably suffered emotional turmoil and significant stress. In consequence, many businesses and homes have been lost. Bankruptcies have occurred. Marriage and families have been wrecked …

Postmasters and others suffered the trauma of criminal prosecution, conviction and punishment, and for some punishment meant lengthy periods of imprisonment.

I received reports that some people held liable for shortfalls became ill as a consequence. Tragically, I heard too of people of whom it is said that they were driven to take their own lives.

Wyn Williams explains why Post Office inquiry human impact and compensation report being published first

Williams starts by saying it is good to see so many people attending. He has been “extremely grateful” for the interest shown in the inquiry, he says.

He thanks those who participated in the inquiry.

He says he has given two speeches about the inquiry in the past. The first was in September 2022, and the second was in July 2023, when he interim report was published.

He says in those speeches he stressed that the inquiry was looking at two areas – the impact of what happened, and whether the compensation schemes were “full, fair and prompt”.

He says he continues to view these as vital elements. And, when he stopped taking evidence, he considered whether he should deal with the human impact as part of the whole report, or whether he should publish that aspect as soon as it was written.

He decided to adopt the latter approach so he could publish as soon as possible, and comment on the compensation schemes. Some aspects of those schemes “could be improved substantially”, he said. So he decide to say so as soon as possible.

But he also concluded that a report covering compensation, without looking at the human impact, would be '“lacking in context”, he says.

Pilgrim says core participants had the chance to read the report under embargo before noon.

Williams will now make a few remarks, she says. But he will not take questions.

Leila Pilgrim, secretary to the inquiry, is introducing Sir Wyn Williams.

She starts by introducing key members of the inquiry team who are present for the statement.

Sir Wyn Williams is about to make a statement about his report.

There is a live feed at the top of the blog.

Around 1,000 people convicted on basis of Post Office Horizon evidence, and for some life became 'close to unbearable', report says

Around 1,000 people were convicted on the basis of Horizon evidence, the report from the inquiry into the Post Office IT scandal says.

Much publicity has surrounded the number of people who were prosecuted and convicted of offences in which data from Horizon played at least a part. Nonetheless, on the evidence available to me I find it difficult to be precise about the actual number. However, it seems to me to be likely that approximately 1,000 persons were prosecuted and convicted throughout the United Kingdom during the period with which the Inquiry is concerned based on Horizon evidence.

It might be thought that very few people who were prosecuted by the Post Office (or by the Prosecuting Authority in Northern Ireland and Scotland) relying upon data from Horizon were acquitted. That would not be correct. I have received evidence which suggests that there were somewhere between 50 and 60 people who were prosecuted, but who were not convicted. It is at least possible that there may have been more. Many of those persons would have been acquitted upon the direction of the presiding judge, but some were acquitted after a trial. However, the fact that persons who were prosecuted were not convicted did not prevent them from suffering many of the adverse impacts which I have already described.

Commenting on the trauma suffered by those prosecuted, Sir Wyn Williams, the inquiry chair, says:

I do not think it is easy to exaggerate the trauma which persons are likely to suffer when they are the subject of criminal investigation, prosecution, conviction and sentence. That is especially so when the persons involved have had no previous experience of these processes. I am sure that the vast majority of persons investigated and prosecuted by the Post Office will have had no such experience. Without exception, in all probability, they will have had no experience of being convicted of offences which render them liable to sentences of imprisonment. In modern times, almost invariably, many months, at best, elapses between the instigation of a criminal investigation and the conclusion of any prosecution consequent upon it. As it happens, the evidence given to this Inquiry has disclosed that in many instances this process has taken years. It is not difficult to imagine the stress and worry which would have consumed many an accused person during such a period of time …

I need not dwell on the suffering of those who were sentenced to immediate terms of imprisonment. Self-evidently, such persons will have suffered greatly. They will have lost their liberty for a specified period of time and they will also have lived for at least part of their sentences under circumstances which, at best, were very restrictive and, at worst, very restrictive and deeply unpleasant. On occasions, life may have seemed close to unbearable.

Contemplating suicide was 'common experience' for victims of Post Office IT scandal, report says

This is what the report says about the way the Post Office scandal led at least 13 people to take their own lives. It says contemplating suicide was a “common experience” for victims.

Following a formal request from the Inquiry dated 18 March 2025, the Post Office named six former postmasters whom, it is claimed by their families, took their own lives as a consequence of Horizon showing an illusory shortfall in branch accounts.17 This information was known to the Post Office largely because of data it holds under the schemes for financial redress which are the subject of Section 4 of this volume but also from reports in the media …

Following a further formal request from the Inquiry on 27 March 2025, the Post Office specified a further seven persons who, according to their families, had taken their own lives as a consequence of Horizon showing an illusory shortfall in branch accounts. These persons were not postmasters but the information was known to the Post Office in relation to six of the deceased persons because of claims made for financial redress and in relation to one of the deceased persons by virtue of reports in the media.

I have also received evidence from at least 59 persons who contemplated suicide at various points in time and who attributed this to their experiences with Horizon and/or the Post Office. This was a common experience across both those who were and were not prosecuted. Ten of the persons who contemplated suicide attempted to take their lives, some on more than one occasion. One postmaster said: “The impact on me of the treatment the Post Office subjected me to has been immeasurable. The mental stress was so great for me that I had a mental breakdown and turned to alcohol as I sunk further into depression. I attempted suicide on several occasions and was admitted to a mental health institution twice.”

At least 10,000 people affected by Post Office IT scandal, inquiry report says

This is what Sir Wyn Williams, the inquiry chair, says in his report about the human impact of the Post Office Horizon IT scandal.

It is almost impossible to ascertain, with any degree of accuracy, the number of persons who have suffered as a result of the misplaced reliance upon data produced by Horizon. I can say, however, with a degree of confidence that there are currently about 10,000 eligible claimants in the schemes providing financial redress and that number is likely to rise at least by hundreds, if not more, over the coming months.

The scale of the suffering endured by those claimants is extremely wide-ranging. At one end of the spectrum, there are claimants who were held liable for small amounts of money allegedly lost to the Post Office – perhaps tens or hundreds of pounds. At the other end of the spectrum, there are claimants who were wrongly convicted and imprisoned, and/or became seriously ill, and/or were declared bankrupt. There are claimants who represent persons who have died. Some of the deceased persons died of natural causes before their convictions were quashed; some have died more recently before their claims for financial redress were determined fully; some are said to have been driven to despair and suicide.

Here is the Post Office inquiry’s report. It runs to 166 pages.

Post Office scandal may have led to more than 13 suicides, inquiry finds

And here is the Guardian report on today’s report from he Post Office Horizon IT inquiry. It is by Julia Kollewe, who was able to read the report under embargo ahead of its publication at noon.

PA Media has posted these snaps about the Post Office Horizon IT inquiry report.

Post Office bosses should have known the Horizon IT system was faulty but they “maintained the fiction that its data was always accurate” when prosecuting subpostmasters, the first tranche of a public inquiry’s final report has concluded.

At least 59 people who experienced problems with the Post Office’s Horizon IT system contemplated suicide, the inquiry has concluded.

Updated

Badenoch backs Tebbit over his 'cricket test', saying he, like her, wanted migrants to come to UK 'because they love it'

In an interview with BBC News about Norman Tebbit, Kemi Badenoch said she had reflected “many times” on what Tebbit meant when he talked about the “cricket test” (see 11.32am), and she said she agreed with him. She explained:

I think what was trying to say is that people who come to this country should come to it because they love it and they want to be a part of it. And I’ve often said similar things myself, that our country is not a hotel, it’s not a dormitory, it’s our home, and we want people who are here to want to contribute to our way of life, to be a part of us. And that was how he expressed that.

Badenoch, who was only a child and living in Nigeria when Tebbit was active in politics, said she had spoken to Tebbit “quite a bit” while he was active in the House of Lords. She added:

He was always urging party to be more conservative, and I think he would be quite pleased with the direction of travel which we’re taking, trying to make sure that people can see authentic conservative principles in every single thing that we do.

There are three ministerial statements in the Commons today after 12.30pm: Pat McFadden, Cabinet Office minister, on the government’s resilience action plan; Heidi Alexander, transport secretary, on road and rail projects’ and Gareth Thomas, business minister, on the Post Office Horizon IT inquiry report.

Rishi Sunak, the former Tory PM, has put out this statement about the death of Norman Tebbit.

Saddened to hear of the passing of Lord Tebbit.

He was a titan of Conservative politics whose resilience, conviction and service left a lasting mark on our party and our country. My thoughts are with his family and all those who knew him.

Sunak was only seven when Tebbit gave up being cabinet minister, but his childhood views of Tebbit are likely to have been influenced by Tebbit’s notorious “cricket test” theory of immigration – that migrants could not be properly integrated if, for example, they continued to support India over England at test cricket.

When he became a Conservative politician, Sunak (who was born in the UK to parents of Indian heritage) avoided saying anything particularly critical about Tebbit’s “test”. But in an interview with the BBC’s Nick Robinson this year he expressed concern about the way some rightwingers have now gone well beyond Tebbit – claiming that non-White Britons cannot count as properly English even if they are playing for the team. As Eastern Eye reports, Sunak said:

It is not enough just to support England at cricket. It turns out it may not be enough to even play for England in cricket or football. You still can’t be English. You look at the composition of our England cricket team, England football team. On this definition you can’t be English even playing for England, let alone supporting them … I found the whole thing slightly ridiculous.

Risks from climate, pensions and bonds leave UK public finances ‘vulnerable’, OBR says

The UK’s public finances are in a “relatively vulnerable position”, with pensions costs, climate change and volatile bond markets all posing significant risks, the independent Office for Budget Responsibility has warned. Heather Stewart has the story here.

Here is the OBR report, Fiscal risks and sustainability.

Graeme Wearden has more coverage on his business live blog.

Will Hayward, the Welsh affairs commentator, has a good take on the new Senedd polling (see 10.48am) in a post on his Substack blog. Here is an extract.

The Tories could be totally wiped out. Due to the electoral system, once a party starts to get towards single figures in terms of vote share, they can end up with no seats. The Welsh Conservatives, who let’s not forget are currently the official opposition in Wales, could end up with no seats in a 96 seat Senedd. Will their leader Darren Millar change course from the Reform tribute act he is currently touring with? I doubt it.

Reform will still not be able to form a government. Given the fact the Tories could be annihilated, there are few places to go for Reform when it comes to coalitions or deals. Speaking to Sky’s Beth Rigby, First Minister Eluned Morgan said she “wouldn’t touch Reform with a barge pole”. Plaid has also ruled out a coalition.

UK government backs French police immobilising small boats, minister says

French police slashing the boats of people smugglers is not “pleasant” but the right tactic, Heidi Alexander, the transport secretary, has said. Jessica Elgot and Peter Walker have the story.

Tebbit was 'hero of modern Conservatism', says Boris Johnson

Boris Johnson, the former Tory PM, has issued this tribute to Norman Tebbit.

Norman Tebbit was a hero of modern Conservatism. In the early 1980s he liberated the British workforce from the socialist tyranny of the closed shop. He tamed the union bosses, and in so doing he helped pave the way for this country’s revival in the 1980s and 1990s.

At a time when the Labour government is now disastrously reversing those crucial reforms we need to remember what he did and why. In his single most famous phrase he once said that in the 1930s his unemployed father had got on his bike and looked for work. That wasn’t a heartless thing to say - as the Labour Party claimed. It was because he believed in thrift and energy and self-reliance. It was because he rejected a culture of easy entitlement.

We mourn the passing of a great patriot, a great Conservative - and today more than ever we need to restore the values of Norman Tebbit to our politics.

Updated

Eluned Morgan says Welsh Labour taking Reform UK 'very seriously' after 2nd poll says it could win Senedd elections

Eluned Morgan, Welsh first minister, has said said Labour is taking the threat from Reform UK “very seriously” following the publication of a new polling suggesting Nigel Farage’s party will come top in next year’s Senedd elections.

The More in Common poll has Reform on 28%, with Plaid Cymru on 26%, Labour on 23% – and the Conservatives far behind on 10%.

This is the second poll in Wales that has put Reform in first place in voting intention for the Senedd. Last month a Find Out Now poll also had Reform in first place, with 29% support, two points ahead of Plaid.

In an interview with Sky News, Morgan accepted there was “a possibility” that Reform could become the largest party in the Senedd, saying it was “really concerning”, but added it would be “difficult for them to rule by themselves”.

But she ruled out entering a coalition with the party, saying: “I wouldn’t touch Reform with a bargepole.”

She also said Labour had to win voters back by being “authentic” and “clear with people about what we stand for”, rather than trying to “out-Reform Reform”. She said:

I think we’ve got to lead with our values. We’re about bringing communities together, not dividing them, and I do think that what Reform is interested in is dividing people and people do need to make choices on things like that.

So, what I won’t be doing in Wales is chasing Reform down a path where we can try and out-Reform Reform. I’m not interested in that, because those aren’t my values.

Updated

Here are some more tribute to Norman Tebbit from politicians and political figures.

From Priti Patel, the former Tory home secretary

Lord Tebbit was a giant of the Conservative Party and British politics. He was a man devoted to promoting freedom and liberty and gave a lifetime of service to our country in the RAF and in Parliament. His formidable record in Government promoting trade, industry and job creation helped lift our country’s economic fortunes and is a legacy to be proud of. Norman spent his life promoting our values and through adversary and challenge, he always displayed great courage.

It was a privilege to know Norman and receive his support and advice.

He will be greatly missed and my thoughts and prayers are with his family and loved ones. May he rest in peace and be reunited with his dear wife.

From DUP MP Jim Shannon

Lord Tebbit, a giant of his generation, staunch ally of Northern Ireland who, with his beloved wife, survived an IRA terrorist attack & yet was undaunted in his facing down those faceless cowards. History will record his service to this nation & my thoughts are with his family.

From Andrew RT Davies, the former Tory leader in Wales

Norman Tebbit was a political titan. A true British patriot, his passion and belief in Britain as the nation state was central to everything he did in politics. Unlike most in public life, he was never afraid to speak the truth.

His huge contribution to public life was unrivalled by most, a remarkable achievement given the tragedy he and his family experienced at the hands of IRA terrorists.

It was to our country’s detriment that Norman Tebbit was forced to retire early from frontline politics, in order to care for his wife Margaret, something he did diligently for decades.

I have no doubts that both Britain and the Conservative Party would be in a much better place today had his influence remained at the top of government in the 1990s.

My thoughts and prayers go out to his family and friends.

May he rest in peace.

From Damian Green, the former first secretary of state, and former chair of the One Nation Conservatives Caucus (at the opposite wing of the Tory party from Tebbit)

The easiest thing to miss about Norman Tebbit was that he was very, very funny. He was always great company in private. RIP

From Nadim Zahawi, the former Tory chancellor

Rest in eternal peace great man. Norman Tebbit was a giant of Conservative politics & Conservative ideals. A man who looked after his beloved wife beautifully after the horrific terror attack by the IRA. A man who nurtured and befriended young conservatives like me. He was great company on a weekend in the country. RIP

From Robert Colvile, the Sunday Times columnist and head of the Centre for Policy Studies thinktank

When I was at the Telegraph, he became one of our star bloggers. What I remember most is the way he tried to answer every comment, and wrote as though their views were just as important as his, even though he was Norman Tebbit and they were eg ‘HugeSimpsonsFan’ or ‘ZaNuLieBore’.

This is what William Hague, the former Tory leader, told Times Radio about Norman Tebbit this morning.

[Tebbit] was definitely on the tough end of everything in the Conservative party. But, of course, the centrepiece of that in those days was bringing trade unions back within the law. And that was a huge issue in the late 70s and early 80s, because previous governments had failed to do that, had really wrestled with that problem and fallen over it. And that Conservative government said, no, you are subject to the law. And of course, we went into a period of better economic growth of less, fewer days lost through strike action. So that toughness was part of the revival of the country’s fortunes in the 80s.

Post Office Horizon IT inquiry to publish first volume of its final report

Later today the Post Office Horizon IT inquiry is publishing the first volume of its final report. It covers the experience of victims, and how the compensation scheme is working. The inquiry will address who was most to blame in a further report.

This is what PA Media has filed on what to expect today.

The first tranche of the long-awaited final report from an inquiry into the Post Office Horizon scandal is set to be published.

More than 900 subpostmasters were wrongfully prosecuted between 1999 and 2015 in what has been dubbed as the worst miscarriage of justice in British legal history.

Many were wrongly convicted of crimes such as theft and false accounting after faulty Horizon software made it look as though money was missing from their accounts.

Subpostmasters’ lives were destroyed – with some bankrupted by legal action and sent to prison.

Today the first volume of the Horizon IT inquiry’s final report will be published – covering the devastating impact on the lives of the scandal’s victims and the compensation process.

The issue of financial redress has frequently been flagged as an issue by subpostmasters – with many still awaiting full compensation.

The various compensation schemes have been criticised by victims as unfair and difficult to navigate – processes which lead campaigner Sir Alan Bates has previously described as “quasi-kangaroo courts”.

Retired judge Sir Wyn Williams, the chairman of the probe, will make a public statement following the report’s publication.

In an interim report published in July 2023, Sir Wyn described legislative changes made to resolve issues with the redress schemes as “a patchwork quilt of compensation schemes… with some holes in it”.

The inquiry was established in 2020, with a number of witnesses giving evidence on the use of Fujitsu’s Horizon system, Post Office governance and the legal action taken against subpostmasters.

In a previous statement addressing the compensation schemes, the Department for Business and Trade said: “This government has quadrupled the total amount paid to affected postmasters to provide them with full and fair redress, with more than £1bn having now been paid to over 7,300 claimants.”

Updated

Tebbit in his own words

One of the characteristics that made Norman Tebbit stand out as a minister was his skill as a communicator; he was pithy, direct, original, unpretentious, often quite nasty. But always interesting. He was not the sort of politician interested in regurgitating the bland ‘line to take’. If Twitter had been around in the 1980s, it would have suited him brilliantly.

PA Media has rounded up some of his best known quotes.

It is certainly safe, in view of the movement to the right of intellectuals and political thinkers, to pronounce the brain death of socialism.

Parliament must not be told a direct untruth, but it’s quite possible to allow them to mislead themselves.

He didn’t riot. He got on his bike and looked for work”

This was Tebbit talking about his father, when he fell out of work. Tebbit never actually uttered the much attributed phrase “on yer bike”.

The BBC is another part of the destruction of Great Britain. The truth is that the BBC doesn’t know that it is biased. It thinks that Guardian reading champagne socialists are the norm.

I’ve never bashed a union in my life.

John Major has the mulishness of a weak man with stupidity.

It’s good to remember the unburied dead and the uncollected rubbish. Most of it can now be seen on the Labour benches in the House of Commons.

The poll tax was a classic case of a good idea being entrusted to Chris Patten and becoming a terrible failure.

Updated

Badenoch leads tributes to Norman Tebbit, 'icon' of Thatcherism, praising his 'stoicism and courage'

Kemi Badenoch, the Conservative leader, has issued this tribute to Norman Tebbit.

Our Conservative family mourns the loss of Lord Tebbit today and I send my sincerest condolences to his loved ones.

Norman Tebbit was an icon in British politics and his death will cause sadness across the political spectrum.

He was one of the leading exponents of the philosophy we now know as Thatcherism and his unstinting service in the pursuit of improving our country should be held up as an inspiration to all Conservatives.

As a minister in Mrs Thatcher’s administration he was one of the main agents of the transformation of our country, notably in taming the trade unions.

But to many of us it was the stoicism and courage he showed in the face of terrorism which inspired us as he rebuilt his political career after suffering terrible injuries in the Brighton bomb, and cared selflessly for his wife Margaret, who was gravely disabled in the bombing – a reminder that he was first and foremost a family man who always held true to his principles.

He never buckled under pressure and he never compromised.

Our nation has lost one of its very best today and I speak for all the Conservative family and beyond in recognising Lord Tebbit’s enormous intellect and profound sense of duty to his country.

May he rest in peace.

Here is Jamie Grierson’s story about the death of Norman Tebbit.

Good morning. Emmanuel Macron, the French president, is starting his state visit to the UK today, three of the most senior cabinet ministers are giving evidence to select committees, and the Post Office Horizon IT inquiry is publishing the first volume of its final report. And it has just been announced that Norman Tebbit, one of the most controversial, and consequential, figures from Margaret Thatcher’s cabinet, has died. It will be a busy day.

This is what PA Media is reporting about Lord Tebbit’s death.

Tory former cabinet minister Lord Norman Tebbit has died aged 94, his son said.

The Conservative grandee was one of Margaret Thatcher’s closest political allies and played a key role in Tory politics for a generation.

As employment secretary he took on the trade unions, and as chairman of the Conservative Party from 1985 to 1987 he helped Mrs Thatcher secure her third general election victory.

He suffered grave injuries in the 1984 Brighton bombing, which left his wife, Margaret, paralysed from the neck down.

Tebbit’s son, William, issued this statement.

At 11.15pm on 7th July 2025 Lord Tebbit died peacefully at home aged 94.

His family ask that their privacy is respected at this time and a further statement regarding funeral arrangements will be made in due course.

Nigel Huddleston, the co-chair of the Conservative party, has issued this tribute.

Very sad to hear about the passing of Norman Tebbit. A true ‘Tory grandee’ who achieved great political heights from a modest background under the aspirational and meritocratic environment of the Thatcher era – and who suffered greatly for his prominence in the IRA Brighton bombing. He will be missed.

Here is the agenda for the day.

9.30am: Keir Starmer chairs cabinet.

9.30am: The Office for Budget Responsibility publishes a report on fiscal risks.

9.30am: The Department for Education publishes provisional national headline results for this year’s key stage 2 Sats exams in primary schools in England.

9.30am: The Office for National Statistics publishes healthy life expectancy figures for England and Wales.

10.30am: Luke Pollard, the armed forces minister, gives evidence to the Commons defence committee on the UK contribution to European security.

Noon: The Post Office Horizon IT inquiry publishes volume one of its final report, covering the impact on victims and compensation.

12.30am: Sir Wyn Williams, the chair of the Post Office inquiry, gives a statement on his report.

1pm: Angela Rayner, the deputy PM and housing secretary, gives evidence to the housing committee on the spending review.

1.30pm: David Lammy, the foreign secretary, gives evidence to the foreign affairs committee.

2pm: Yvette Cooper, the home secretary, gives evidence to the Lords justice and home affairs committee.

4.15pm: President Macron gives a speech to MPs and peers in the Royal Gallery in the House of Lords.

If you want to contact me, please post a message below the line when comments are open (normally between 10am and 3pm at the moment), or message me on social media. I can’t read all the messages BTL, but if you put “Andrew” in a message aimed at me, I am more likely to see it because I search for posts containing that word.

If you want to flag something up urgently, it is best to use social media. You can reach me on Bluesky at @andrewsparrowgdn.bsky.social. The Guardian has given up posting from its official accounts on X, but individual Guardian journalists are there, I still have my account, and if you message me there at @AndrewSparrow, I will see it and respond if necessary.

I find it very helpful when readers point out mistakes, even minor typos. No error is too small to correct. And I find your questions very interesting too. I can’t promise to reply to them all, but I will try to reply to as many as I can, either BTL or sometimes in the blog.

 

Leave a Comment

Required fields are marked *

*

*